¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Subscription Approval Problem


 

I have a member who applied for membership, so I tried to reply by email to approve but the email bounced back.

Meanwhile in the "Activity" log reads correctly "johnsmith@... for membership"
Yet if I look at the Directory he is not listed as pending nor approved.

So how can approve something I can't see?

Kevin Conod
kdconod@...


J_Catlady
 

I would report that to Mark ([email protected]) and give him all the details, including copies of emails, a link to your activity log, etc.

On Sun, Feb 18, 2018 at 6:58 PM, Kevin Conod via Groups.Io <kdconod@...> wrote:
I have a member who applied for membership, so I tried to reply by email to approve but the email bounced back.

Meanwhile in the "Activity" log reads correctly "johnsmith@... for membership"
Yet if I look at the Directory he is not listed as pending nor approved.

So how can approve something I can't see?

Kevin Conod
kdconod@...



 

The Directory may or may not have people listed, depending on their Profile choices.? You should be looking at Admin > Members > Pending Members.

Duane
--
Help: /static/help
GMF's Wiki: /g/GroupManagersForum/wiki
Search button at the top of Messages list


 

Good point - I did double-check and make sure I was looking at the correct directory in the Admin section but no dice.
?

Kevin Conod
kdconod@...




From: Duane <txpigeon@...>
To: [email protected]
Sent: Sunday, February 18, 2018 11:04 PM
Subject: Re: [GMF] Subscription Approval Problem

The Directory may or may not have people listed, depending on their Profile choices.? You should be looking at Admin > Members > Pending Members.

Duane


 

Kevin,

I have a member who applied for membership, so I tried to reply by
email to approve but the email bounced back.
I take it your received a "Subscription Approval Needed" email that you replied to. What error message did the bounce back contain?

It is possible for a member who applies via web to open their Subscription Options and Unsubscribe (withdraw their request) before you reply. If he/she did the error response would be:

500 That subscription no longer exists. Most likely the person decided
to unsubscribe.
However the Activity log should then say the member "left via web", sometime after the entry showing his/her application. Too, you would have received a "Subscriber has left" notification, if you have elected to receive such.

Meanwhile in the "Activity" log reads correctly
"johnsmith@... for membership"
Does it say "via web"? or "via email"?

So how can approve something I can't see?
The real question is whether there was still an pending membership to approve. The error response to your attempted approval by email suggests that was no longer the case.

Shal


--
Help: /static/help
More Help: /g/GroupManagersForum/wiki
Even More Help: Search button at the top of Messages list


 

That is the message I received and "subscribed?via web" does appear in Activity log...
Yet he did not unsubscribe nor does "left via web" appear in the log.?

In the end, its good now. I was able to send another invitation and the member accepted it this morning and all is well.

Kevin Conod
kdconod@...




From: Shal Farley <shals2nd@...>
To: [email protected]
Sent: Monday, February 19, 2018 3:04 AM
Subject: Re: [GMF] Subscription Approval Problem

Kevin,

> I have a member who applied for membership, so I tried to reply by
> email to approve but the email bounced back.

I take it your received a "Subscription Approval Needed" email that you
replied to. What error message did the bounce back contain?

It is possible for a member who applies via web to open their
Subscription Options and Unsubscribe (withdraw their request) before you
reply. If he/she did the error response would be:

> 500 That subscription no longer exists. Most likely the person decided
> to unsubscribe.

However the Activity log should then say the member "left via web",
sometime after the entry showing his/her application. Too, you would
have received a "Subscriber has left" notification, if you have elected
to receive such.

> Meanwhile in the "Activity" log reads correctly
> "johnsmith@... for membership"

Does it say "via web"? or "via email"?

> So how can approve something I can't see?

The real question is whether there was still an pending membership to
approve. The error response to your attempted approval by email suggests
that was no longer the case.

Shal