That is the message I received and "subscribed?via web" does appear in Activity log... Yet he did not unsubscribe nor does "left via web" appear in the log.? In the end, its good now. I was able to send another invitation and the member accepted it this morning and all is well. Kevin Conod kdconod@... From: Shal Farley <shals2nd@...> To: [email protected] Sent: Monday, February 19, 2018 3:04 AM Subject: Re: [GMF] Subscription Approval Problem Kevin, > I have a member who applied for membership, so I tried to reply by > email to approve but the email bounced back. I take it your received a "Subscription Approval Needed" email that you replied to. What error message did the bounce back contain? It is possible for a member who applies via web to open their Subscription Options and Unsubscribe (withdraw their request) before you reply. If he/she did the error response would be: > 500 That subscription no longer exists. Most likely the person decided > to unsubscribe. However the Activity log should then say the member "left via web", sometime after the entry showing his/her application. Too, you would have received a "Subscriber has left" notification, if you have elected to receive such. > Meanwhile in the "Activity" log reads correctly > "johnsmith@... for membership" Does it say "via web"? or "via email"? > So how can approve something I can't see? The real question is whether there was still an pending membership to approve. The error response to your attempted approval by email suggests that was no longer the case. Shal |