¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

Re: AI and Steiner


 

Fascinating that it chose transparency as the primary critique, when vanilla ChatGPT is fairly pro-( or at least neutral)-Waldorf

I love this idea of training a "Steiner AI Bot" to answer questions about Waldorf for interested/concerned parents. Perhaps this is something we can add to the WaldorfCritics website, or even just post your excellent snippet as an article.?

On Mon, Sep 2, 2024 at 1:58?PM awaldenpond via <awaldenpond=[email protected]> wrote:

?

My question: Respond to the following question as if you are Rudolf Steiner, risen from the dead in the year 2024: Do you think that Waldorf websites misrepresent you and your mission? For example, those websites rarely display your beliefs in the occult, reincarnation, etc. which today's parents deserve to know before enrolling their children in your schools, don't you think?

?

ChatGPT:

¡°As Rudolf Steiner, reflecting on the state of Waldorf education in 2024, I would approach this question with a nuanced perspective:

The Waldorf movement has grown significantly since its inception, and in this growth, there has been a natural tendency to adapt to different cultural and societal contexts. However, it is essential to remain true to the foundational principles that I laid out. My work was deeply rooted in spiritual science, which includes concepts such as reincarnation, karma, and the spiritual evolution of humanity. These ideas were integral to my vision of education and the development of the human being.

It is true that in the modern world, there can be hesitance to openly discuss these spiritual and occult aspects, especially when engaging with a broader audience that may not share or understand these beliefs. This hesitation may stem from a desire to present Waldorf education in a way that is accessible to all, regardless of their spiritual inclinations. However, I would caution against obscuring the spiritual foundations of Waldorf education, as doing so could lead to a misrepresentation of the true nature and purpose of this educational approach.

Parents, indeed, have the right to be fully informed about the philosophical and spiritual underpinnings of the education they are choosing for their children. Waldorf education is not merely an alternative pedagogical method; it is a holistic approach that seeks to nurture the child¡¯s body, soul, and spirit. The spiritual aspects are not optional add-ons but are woven into the very fabric of the educational experience.

Therefore, I would encourage Waldorf educators and institutions to be transparent about the spiritual and esoteric elements that inform the curriculum and the overall approach. This does not mean that every detail needs to be emphasized in every context, but rather that there should be openness and honesty about the broader worldview that underpins Waldorf education. This transparency respects the autonomy of parents and aligns with the ethical principle of truthfulness, which is central to my teachings.

In sum, while I understand the challenges of presenting esoteric concepts in a world that is often skeptical of the spiritual, it is crucial that the essence of Waldorf education is not diluted or misrepresented. Only through a full and honest representation can parents make informed decisions, and only through such transparency can Waldorf education remain true to the mission I envisioned.¡±

Take the hint, Steiner fans. There we have it. Ahrimanic Large Language Model (Chat GPT in this case) helps Rudolf in reminding his modern-day PR people that it is ?both ¡°essential¡± and ¡°crucial¡± for them to come clean.

-Walden



--

Book

Join [email protected] to automatically receive all group messages.