|
Good afternoon GIN and PEZ:
Briefly; Yes I have read your contiguous report @ This is much improved and helpful to me; but please understand that its falls considerably short of Dr. Kirby's stated desires and expectations. Perhaps the frustration expressed by Dr. Kirby, and shared by myself an others that may be following or attempting to follow may best be communicated by example. I have attached and renamed (for my own convenience), the first of a well written 5 part series of which a link was provided us early in this thread. This example represents the form of a well written report and I believe also represents Dr. Kirby's inference of a document entitled "Full Final Report". I should also point out that after approximately 10 minutes of searching the forum, I gave up on locating your post that provides the links to your documentation and the link to this document specifically. I finally resorted instead to providing my own downloaded copy to serve here as a prototype example of a report that an uninformed reader might expect when being presented with closing arguments of an informed third party's research. Respectfully; This is intended as a technical criticism of your communication style, and not a personal one. Our frustrations have been expressed sufficiently and clearly to this point that nonstop repetition should be unnecessary. Perhaps in your own words... The writers have been warned. My own recent post: /g/nanovna-users/message/5075 ... at the time of this writing... can be mostly ignored. I see the important content is being addressed. I acknowledge your response as noted and I will attempt to refrain from revisiting this topic, and hopefully limit my comments to productive or otherwise constructive ones. I will also acknowledge that it is your intent to terminate this thread with a more or less formal presentation of your work here with the NanoVNA, the introduction of your AnyVNA definition, summary of results, refinements of your algorithm(s), and ... most anticipated... your conclusions. Finally, I gratefully acknowledge your responses to my questions, guiding my understanding, and in sharing of ownership in the task of breaking through the barrier of communications. I see responses to my questions as this is being composed, so I will maintain patience and permit you time to respond. 73 Gary, N3GO -- 73 Gary, N3GO |
