¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io

New MacBook Pro Boots When Lid is Opened


 

Well I started setting up my 2019 16¡± MBP, sand I am learning some new things already. ?For one, simply opening its lid causes it to boot. ?I found a command to run in Terminal that will turn that off, but if you reset VRAM, then you have to reset it again. ?Actually that feature also on MBP 2016 and later models and the MBA 2018 model.

If you have one of those models, what do you think about that feature? ?Do you like, or dislike it?

For those who elected to turn that feature off, have you encountered any drawbacks after doing so?
Thanks,
--
Bev in TX


 

My view is, why would you open the screen unless you wanted to use it, so booting from shutdown?makes sense to me. This is an obvious follow-on from wake from sleep.

Otto

On Fri, 6 Mar 2020 at 00:07, Bev in TX <countryone77@...> wrote:
Well I started setting up my 2019 16¡± MBP, sand I am learning some new things already.? For one, simply opening its lid causes it to boot.? I found a command to run in Terminal that will turn that off, but if you reset VRAM, then you have to reset it again.? Actually that feature also on MBP 2016 and later models and the MBA 2018 model.

If you have one of those models, what do you think about that feature?? Do you like, or dislike it?

For those who elected to turn that feature off, have you encountered any drawbacks after doing so?


 

Howdy.

Article on how to disable boot when lid is opened.

<>

EaszPeazy in Terminal. You can copy/paste the command from the article
into Terminal.

Denver Dan



On Thu, 05 Mar 2020 16:07:10 -0800, Bev in TX wrote:
Well I started setting up my 2019 16¡± MBP, sand I am learning some
new things already. For one, simply opening its lid causes it to
boot. I found a command to run in Terminal that will turn that off,
but if you reset VRAM, then you have to reset it again. Actually
that feature also on MBP 2016 and later models and the MBA 2018 model.

If you have one of those models, what do you think about that
feature? Do you like, or dislike it?

For those who elected to turn that feature off, have you encountered
any drawbacks after doing so?
Thanks,
--
Bev in TX
[|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|]

iSent from iDan's GyazMail on my MacPro 2019


 

Otto:

It would seem logical that you wouldn't want your computer on when you were cleaning the keyboard and perhaps the screen. I've found that cleaning the keyboard is best done with the computer off.

John


 

On Mar 6, 2020, at 7:11 AM, Daniel Settles <denver1.dan1@...> wrote:

Article on how to disable boot when lid is opened.

<>

EaszPeazy in Terminal. You can copy/paste the command from the article
into Terminal.

Denver Dan
Thanks, that is one of the articles that I read. I don¡¯t like the fact that you have to turn it off again every time you reset VRAM. So I was trying to get folks opinions on whether this feature is something to just become acclimated or if it would be a bother.

--
Bev in TX


 

¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

Yes, I think that is what you would want to happen most of the time. ?And since it boots and shuts down so fast, it would be easy to shut it down in the less frequent situations when you didn¡¯t want it on.

On Mar 6, 2020, at 4:55 AM, Otto Nikolaus via Groups.Io <otto.nikolaus@...> wrote:

My view is, why would you open the screen unless you wanted to use it, so booting from shutdown?makes sense to me. This is an obvious follow-on from wake from sleep.

Otto

On Fri, 6 Mar 2020 at 00:07, Bev in TX <countryone77@...> wrote:
Well I started setting up my 2019 16¡± MBP, sand I am learning some new things already.? For one, simply opening its lid causes it to boot.? I found a command to run in Terminal that will turn that off, but if you reset VRAM, then you have to reset it again.? Actually that feature also on MBP 2016 and later models and the MBA 2018 model.

If you have one of those models, what do you think about that feature?? Do you like, or dislike it?

For those who elected to turn that feature off, have you encountered any drawbacks after doing so?

--
Bev in TX


 

Howdy.

Bev, I'm not aware of a VRAM reset.

You may be thinking of NVRAM which means Non Volatile Random Access
Memory.

There is a startup maintenance command called Zap the PRAM which is a
reset of NVRAM aka Parameter RAM. This type of PRAM holds settings
that are accessed by the Mac before it finishes booting.

Denver Dan



On Fri, 6 Mar 2020 11:29:56 -0600, Bev in TX wrote:
EaszPeazy in Terminal. You can copy/paste the command from the article
into Terminal.

Denver Dan
Thanks, that is one of the articles that I read. I don¡¯t like the
fact that you have to turn it off again every time you reset VRAM.
So I was trying to get folks opinions on whether this feature is
something to just become acclimated or if it would be a bother.

--
Bev in TX
[|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|]

iSent from iDan's GyazMail on my MacPro 2019


 

On Mar 6, 2020, at 11:53 AM, Daniel Settles <denver1.dan1@...> wrote:

Bev, I'm not aware of a VRAM reset.

You may be thinking of NVRAM which means Non Volatile Random Access
Memory.

There is a startup maintenance command called Zap the PRAM which is a
reset of NVRAM aka Parameter RAM. This type of PRAM holds settings
that are accessed by the Mac before it finishes booting.

Denver Dan
Of course you are right - that¡¯s what I meant. In fact the command is ¡°nvram¡±.

--
Bev in TX


 

Howdy.

Or, boot with Option Command p r pressed.

If you have a startup chime, keep the 4 keys pressed until you hear the
chime a 2nd time.

Denver Dan


On Fri, 6 Mar 2020 13:33:30 -0600, Bev in TX wrote:

There is a startup maintenance command called Zap the PRAM which is a
reset of NVRAM aka Parameter RAM. This type of PRAM holds settings
that are accessed by the Mac before it finishes booting.

Denver Dan
Of course you are right - that¡¯s what I meant. In fact the command
is ¡°nvram¡±.
[|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|][|]

iSent from iDan's GyazMail on my MacPro 2019


 

¿ªÔÆÌåÓý


On Mar 6, 2020, at 1:33 PM, Bev in TX via Groups.Io <countryone77@...> wrote:

On Mar 6, 2020, at 11:53 AM, Daniel Settles <denver1.dan1@...> wrote:

Bev, I'm not aware of a VRAM reset.

You may be thinking of NVRAM which means Non Volatile Random Access
Memory.

There is a startup maintenance command called Zap the PRAM which is a
reset of NVRAM aka Parameter RAM. ?This type of PRAM holds settings
that are accessed by the Mac before it finishes booting.

Denver Dan

Of course you are right - ?that¡¯s what I meant. ?In fact the command is ¡°nvram¡±.
For those who like more details, PRAM Is different from NVRAM. ?The following 2018 article says, ¡°?Modern Macs no longer use PRAM; they instead use something called NVRAM (NV for non-volatile)...¡±. ?I¡¯m not sure what they mean by ¡°modern¡±.


--
Bev in TX