Yeah. You're right Jim.I hadn't thought it through that far and
you're right about the many handy applications. I use them a lot.
Alek VK6APK.
On 3/06/2024 12:53 am, Jim VE7RF wrote:
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Alek, I don't think the opto idea would work.? ?All the
resistors are in series, and regardless of value..... the
current is the same. (current in a series circuit is the same).?
IE: say 7500 vdc supply, and 25 x 100k @ 3 watt mof resistor is
series.... then add a 26th resistor (1666 ohms).? Current in the
string is just 3 ma.? ?3 ma x 1666 ohms = 5 vdc.
If an opto, whose input side operated on 5 vdc..... the same
opto will draw a lot more than 3 ma on it's input side, to
function.? ?Most are typ 10-20 ma on the input side.? ?Where is
that current going to come from??
I may well be missing something here.?
?
And for K6LPM, opto's are alive and well, used all the time.?
?The ODC-22's I use to key the sped up vac relays operate in
100u secs....and rls in 750u seconds.? They also have 5 kv
isolation between the input side and the output side.? ? They
came in a choice of? 9-15-24 vdc input sides? (with each of
those having a wide variance)? and a choice of either 60 vdc @ 3
amps ccs...or 200 vdc @ 1 amp for the sec side.? ?That's just 1
opto.? There are hundreds more to pick from.?
Switch transistors are a lot faster.? Like 3.6 microseconds,
300V rated at 500ma.? $1.85 from mouser.? ?My issue with switch
transistors is.... IF they ever failed shorted, then the entire
OCV? (open circuit voltage) is applied to the xcvr. IMO, the
huge isolation between input and output of the opto is a huge
advantage.? The input and output are totally isolated from each
other.? The opto part is just the laser / light firing a beam
from one side to the other.? There is no mechanical or
electrical connection between the input and output.? ?The output
side is essentially just a SPST-NO electronic switch.?
?