Keyboard Shortcuts
Likes
Search
SWAN discoverers
开云体育Hi Michael and Vladimir, ? I actually have Michael at 11 SWAN comets (or 12 if you count 58P which Michael spotted in SWAN in April 2020) ? C/2004 H6, C/2004 V13, P/2005 P3, C/2005 T4, C/2006 M4, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2015 P3 , C/2020 F8, C/2021 D1 and C/2025 F2. ? If my records are correct, I have Vladimir with 7 SWAN comets (some shared with Michael and/or me): ? P/2005 P3, C/2011 Q4, C/2012 E2, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2023 A2, and C/2025 F2 ? My count is at 9 (many of which also shared with Michael and/or Vladimir), though as Michael pointed out one of these (C/2012 V4) turned out to be the recovery of D/1827 M1 = 273P Pons-Gambart, and another P/2018 HT3 was linked to an asteroid.? --Rob ? From: [email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Michael Mattiazzo via groups.io
Sent: Friday, April 11, 2025 3:57 PM To: [email protected] Subject: EXTERNAL: Re: [comets-ml] C/2025 F2 (SWAN) + coordinate conversion check ? Thanks Vladimir. I’m sure Rob has also found quite a few over the years, including some non SWAN named ones such as 273P Pons-Gambart and P/2018 HT_3 The recovery of 58P was also a SWAN find. cheers, Michael ? From:
[email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Vladimir Bezugly via groups.io ? Hi Michael. If I correctly understood this - we all should to congratulate you with a TEN comet that you discovered in the SWAN data! So my congratulations to you with this milestone! Vladimir. |
开云体育Rob, ? C/2015 F3 is not my find. (shared between you and Vladimir) Lost comet 58p was spotted by Hua Su in SWAN (who should have been properly credited). I followed up with the ground confirmation. ? Cheers, Michael ? From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Matson, Rob D. via groups.io
Sent: Tuesday, 15 April 2025 4:43 AM To: [email protected] Subject: [comets-ml] SWAN discoverers ? Hi Michael and Vladimir, ? I actually have Michael at 11 SWAN comets (or 12 if you count 58P which Michael spotted in SWAN in April 2020) ? C/2004 H6, C/2004 V13, P/2005 P3, C/2005 T4, C/2006 M4, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2015 P3 , C/2020 F8, C/2021 D1 and C/2025 F2. ? If my records are correct, I have Vladimir with 7 SWAN comets (some shared with Michael and/or me): ? P/2005 P3, C/2011 Q4, C/2012 E2, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2023 A2, and C/2025 F2 ? My count is at 9 (many of which also shared with Michael and/or Vladimir), though as Michael pointed out one of these (C/2012 V4) turned out to be the recovery of D/1827 M1 = 273P Pons-Gambart, and another P/2018 HT3 was linked to an asteroid.? --Rob ? From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Michael Mattiazzo via groups.io ? Thanks Vladimir. I’m sure Rob has also found quite a few over the years, including some non SWAN named ones such as 273P Pons-Gambart and P/2018 HT_3 The recovery of 58P was also a SWAN find. cheers, Michael ? From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Vladimir Bezugly via groups.io ? Hi Michael. If I correctly understood this - we all should to congratulate you with a TEN comet that you discovered in the SWAN data! So my congratulations to you with this milestone! Vladimir. |
开云体育Hi Michael – I’ll update my records. For some reason I had C/2015 F3 shared amongst the three of us. ? I found old posts about 58P that I misinterpreted to mean that you had found it telescopically after being cued by spotting it in SWAN. I apparently assumed self-cuing, so I’ll correct that to Hua Su.? --Rob ? From: [email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Michael Mattiazzo via groups.io
Sent: Monday, April 14, 2025 5:21 PM To: [email protected] Subject: EXTERNAL: Re: [comets-ml] SWAN discoverers ? Rob, ? C/2015 F3 is not my find. (shared between you and Vladimir) Lost comet 58p was spotted by Hua Su in SWAN (who should have been properly credited). I followed up with the ground confirmation. ? Cheers, Michael ? From:
[email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Matson, Rob D. via groups.io ? Hi Michael and Vladimir, ? I actually have Michael at 11 SWAN comets (or 12 if you count 58P which Michael spotted in SWAN in April 2020) ? C/2004 H6, C/2004 V13, P/2005 P3, C/2005 T4, C/2006 M4, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2015 P3 , C/2020 F8, C/2021 D1 and C/2025 F2. ? If my records are correct, I have Vladimir with 7 SWAN comets (some shared with Michael and/or me): ? P/2005 P3, C/2011 Q4, C/2012 E2, C/2015 C2, C/2015 F3, C/2023 A2, and C/2025 F2 ? My count is at 9 (many of which also shared with Michael and/or Vladimir), though as Michael pointed out one of these (C/2012 V4) turned out to be the recovery of D/1827 M1 = 273P Pons-Gambart, and another P/2018 HT3 was linked to an asteroid.? --Rob ? From:
[email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Michael Mattiazzo via groups.io ? Thanks Vladimir. I’m sure Rob has also found quite a few over the years, including some non SWAN named ones such as 273P Pons-Gambart and P/2018 HT_3 The recovery of 58P was also a SWAN find. cheers, Michael ? From:
[email protected] <[email protected]>
On Behalf Of Vladimir Bezugly via groups.io ? Hi Michael. If I correctly understood this - we all should to congratulate you with a TEN comet that you discovered in the SWAN data! So my congratulations to you with this milestone! Vladimir. |