v17.1.15??????? -> Same bug and worse (see below).
v24.0.12??????? -> Same bug.
?
On v17.1.15 the same "no NPN" bug appears and v17.1.15 also fails when the NPN is included.
Even with the NPN included, v17.1.15 says:
?
Can't find definition of model X10:MMBT5551
Can't find definition of model X10:MMBT5551
Error on line 205 : q:x10:2 x10:qc x10:dzkl x10:qe2 0?:0? x10:lobt5551
???? Unable to find definition of model "x10:mmbt5551"
Error on line 210 : q:x10:1 x10:qc x10:dzkl x10:qe1 0?:0? x10:lobt5551
???? Unable to find definition of model "x10:mmbt5551"
?
There appears to be no way to do AKO: in a sub-circuit on v17.1.15.
Sent:?Sunday, February 09, 2025 at 5:44 PM From:?"Andy I via groups.io" <AI.egrps+io@...> To:[email protected] Subject:?Re: [LTspice] AKO: Fails When Placed in Sub-Schematic
On Sun, Feb 9, 2025 at 05:22 PM, eewiz wrote:
In a .subckt, writing ".model LoBT5551 ako:MMBT5551 (Bf=80)" without the NPN produces;
"Can't find definition of model LOBT5551".
That error message suggests that LTspice was unable to correctly find (or read) the ".model LoBT5551" statement at all, in that case inside the subcircuit without the "NPN" included.? It apparently rejected it.
?
It would be interesting to investigate how far back (through LTspice versions) that bug was there.