I think you want to select "Listed in directory, private archives."? If you choose one that says "public archives", anyone can read the messages, even if they're not a member of the group, like here on GMF.? Being listed in the directory allows people to search the available groups to find yours.
Duane
--
Help:
/static/helpGMF's Wiki:
/g/GroupManagersForum/wikiSearch button at the top of Messages list