Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
- AlwaysLearning
- Messages
Search
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Games)
KT
I think that's a pretty big assumption that folks who play games don't *also* do the sort of things you're talking about. It's not either/or. Tuck |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive G...
I'm often heard to mutter "These people learned to drive playing Nintendo and haven't figured out that this freeway doesn't HAVE a Restart button." We expected Marty to be in the hospital a time or two in his youth. ??He was a brave baby. ?But he's a cautious and skillful older kid. ?He stepped on a nail and got a tetanus shot. ?In all his skating (roller blade and icerink) and bike and skateboard stuff, he's never been hurt. He gives good advice to other kids too. ?So because he's not reckless, I'm not worried. When I learned to drive I didn't even know how to start the car, an automatic, the first day of driving. ?My three car-mates had already driven some with their parents. ?I was clue-free and not great at spatial reasoning, and I've never had worse than dents in the driveway and fenderbenders. ?I would have done better with some Nintendo practice in my own youth. ?Bummer not even Pong was invented yet. Sandra |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Ga...
In a message dated 11/27/01 11:39:46 AM Mountain Standard Time, ecsamhill@... writes:
Does anyone have insight into where satisfaction at a job well done comes from? ?Can it only be destroyed by being a perfectionist, or are there other ways it might be undermined? That's a topic about the size of the universe, I think. Different people are more or less affected by others' opinions or expressions. ?Some are SO dependent on others' approval that it's considered detrimental (co-dependency). ?Some care so little about the opinions of others it's considered pathological (sociopath?). ? Balance. No sense living your future on an old accomplishment. ?"I was a cheerleader!" shouldn't be depended on to take a woman happily into her 40's. It seems to me those the happiest with their accomplishments are those who were the most realistic about what they hoped to do, what the risk of failure was, who were doing it selflessly and generously, and who plan to try again to do it better another time anyway. ?Those who would have been happy with failure too seem to have a healthier happiness with success. Sandra |
Re: (unknown)
. And is he old enough to have his own lower shelf in the kitchen that you
can stock with whatever he'll eat? (Plus a few of your own selections, of course!) It's all about control at that age; take yourself out of the loop as much as possible. I think I will do this. He really likes tht he can now open the pantry door and take out food. I think I will use the bottom shelf for snacks. Great idea! Elissa |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Ga...
but I'm concerned about the creation and manipulation of desire for power. Maybe it's only an acknowledgement and an exercise in the very REAL desire for power kids have. ?If they can have the feeling of power without needing to bully other humans or steal stereos to get it, I say more power to 'em!! Sandra |
Re: (unknown)
Karen Matlock
¿ªÔÆÌåÓýGood
*days*? I have good *mornings* that degenerate into yelling, disrespect, and
(the recent favorite) the Disgruntled Glare. Yesterday was such a day. Had I
been dh, ds10 would have been grounded for at least a week. Since I try not to
resort to meaningless retribution, I got him out of the situation, let him stew
awhile, and by evening, I was walking by the couch where he was sitting and he
said quietly, "I love you," whereupon I gave him a big ol' hug, the kind that
ds10s hate (in public, anyway.) Now I know yours is two and mine is ten, but the
principle is the same. I try to stop and feel where they are, when I haven't and
I've been an ogre, I apologize. When mine was that age and I blew up, I'd put
myself in time out and tell him so. The novelty was enough to stop the behavior
and he wanted to comfort me. Setting limits is just the household rules, which
apply to everyone: respect others' property, use appropriate language, keep up
with your responsibilities. I have to show him that I do that myself, as well as
showing what I do when I screw up. Please don't be a perfect mother; I had one
(still do) and I'm still getting over it.
?
As far
as the junk food; toddlers need surprisingly little food volume and variety
isn't a concern yet. As long as he's not underweight (if he is, this is a
medical issue instead) then I would offer a selection of foods and stand back.
I've never harped on the issue, and?I'm fortunate that it's not (much of)
an problem here. You can find "junky" looking foods that aren't too bad,
health-nut-wise, just check out the cereal and cookie aisle at your neighborhood
health food store. If all he wanted was rice krispies and milk three times a
day, that's not so bad either, just throw in a multivitamin now and then. And is
he old enough to have his own lower shelf in the kitchen that you can stock with
whatever he'll eat? (Plus a few of your own selections, of course!) It's all
about control at that age; take yourself out of the loop as much as possible.
?
Karen
cautiously unlurking here
? ?-----Original Message-----
From: ElissaJC@... [mailto:ElissaJC@...] Sent: Tuesday, November 27, 2001 7:19 AM To: AlwaysLearning@... Subject: [AlwaysLearning] (unknown) This is a question I decided to send to this list in addition to another |
(No subject)
This is a question I decided to send to this list in addition to another
list: OK, Here is my question (Please be gentle with your answers! LOL) Once the above (the above was a statement regarding kids that through tantrums to get what they want in stores and the writer's opinion that it is due to the parent not being consistant in their responses thereby increasing the child's tantrum - totally paraphrased) has become a pattern - how does one change it? How does one set the limit yet still maintain respect and teh child autonomy? I tend to have good days (respecting their wishes, everyone cooperating, watching the hunger/anger/lonely/tired thing, modeling behavior and then all of a sudden I realize that there has been some yelling, disrespect etc and I'm not sure what got us there. Also, the eating issue (I really wish S was here to answer this one) My two year old is down to eating nothing until he gets junk. Would removing it from the house for a period of time help? Might it give him the space to try other healthier foods and realize he likes them? I don't want to be a food controller yet I am starting to become concerned over his eating habits. Yesterday he ate a bowl of rice crispies with milk and then nothing else! He is still nursing so that eases my fear somewhat. I have also thought about not arguing and letting him nurse as much as desired but I am at that nursing stage where it is starting to get a little irritating physically as my cycle ebbs and flows (pun intended LOL) Elissa |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Ga...
My oldest (17 tomorrow) has her first behind-the-wheel driving lesson on Thursday morning at 10 am.
I can only WISH she'd been playing Nintendo for years!!!!! I learned to drive in a simulator -- it was great fun and VERY VERY VERY good. I felt comfortable by the time I was behind the wheel of a real car. I can't believe she's going to get behind the wheel of a car and just DRIIIIIIIIVE!! Not that I'm nervous --- but AAAAACKKKKKK!!!!!!! --pam |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Games)
I started volunteering at an animal shelter four years ago. A few women
with good intentions got in way over their heads with a no kill shelter. Before they knew it they had forty five dogs and dozens of cats. I went there looking for my friend's cat who had vanished. They had no money except what they could personally contribute. I felt the only thing I could do was plunge in and help. It cost us a small fortune. I spent more on that volunteer work than any of us have ever spent in the pursuit of entertainment. Not only the money but the commitment of time. My son was with me but for months on end I never had any time with my husband. New cats were coming in all the time. People would say, if we didn't take the cats they'd be killed. So naturally we'd try to make room. They would have to be quarantined, vaccinated, spayed. Each new cat cost the shelter (us) a minimum of $100. (that's if they weren't sick ) and that didn't include food and litter pan, etc. One of the very committed volunteers left when her husband threatened divorce over the issue. Things are better at the shelter after an organized fund raising drive, sponsors and several grants, but the point is, doing something *real* can cost plenty. It can tear you up emotionally, threaten a happy home life and put you in debt. Yes, it can be worth it, but it's not always the beautiful picture of fulfillment painted by the TV commercials. I have found a replacement and am taking some time off. Maybe forever. Where's that chess board... Deb L, also vegan, HI Makana!! |
Re: (unknown)
In a message dated 11/27/2001 8:38:10 AM Pacific Standard Time, SandraDodd@... writes:
Let him hold something interesting that you're buying, something unbreakable but colorful and fun. Ah - memories..... As soon as we got to the grocery store we'd go to the bags of dry beans and split peas and stuff like that. They'd pick out a "baby." They cuddle and play with their bag of beans all through the store - talk to it and sing to it and so on. I don't know how this whole thing started - I think it was by accident with my oldest and she passed it down to the younger kids. --pam |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Gam...
In a message dated 11/27/2001 1:05:04 AM Pacific Standard Time, vegan4planet@... writes:
I will try to be more careful about how and what I post. I really don't Well - it is always nice to have someone around willing to voice thoughts that might be worth considering even if they are unpopular among unschoolers. As long as you don't get upset when people disagree with you! I mean, I disagreed with you about these kinds of games not being satisfying for the reasons you gave, but it made me think about how this is one of those things where there is something inherent in them that makes people always want more and more. And that is worth thinking about. It isn't the same as playing a game of checkers or a game of backgammon or even a game of Pictionary. There are all these things to BUY and keep on buying to add to your set. So, ongoing money expenditure is involved and that makes it different and worth spending some time thinking about. And - there is an obsessive quality to them -- that is absent in other kinds of games. I think THAT is the crux of the anxiety that parents sometimes feel -- it makes us uncomfortable when our kids are obsessive about anything. Why? --pam |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Ga...
In a message dated 11/27/01 9:15:17 AM Mountain Standard Time, PSoroosh@... writes:
. I'd sure rather have them developing that sense of distance and hand-eye coordination now, then wait until they're behind the wheel of their first car, for example! OH! I've had that thought in my mind a lot lately, now that Kirby is fifteen and talking about driver's ed. ?I have no doubt that he'll be a really good driver, because he's really good at Nintendo games, and he's physically cautious in general. ? As some of you come across and watch the new Nintendo Game Cube game Monkeyball, watch what fine movement is required to go through those mazes. ?I watched Kirby and Marty play it the first time they picked it up and thought "This will make them better drivers." ? And before someone snorts and says "That's not real and cars are," I will say that I see them care more about keeping a character on an intricate course than some of the drivers I saw yesterday cared about keeping their car in a lane of traffic! Sandra |
Re: Toddler Eating
In a message dated 11/27/01 9:11:35 AM Mountain Standard Time, Otterspur@... writes:
." Those who won't eat sliced cheese Grated cheese goes over well here. ?I still, even though the youngest is ten, grate about a third again more cheese than I need, because it will be eaten as soon as it leave the grater. Sandra |
Re: 4yo reading questions
I'm not sure how much he's actually reading The cool thing is that you don't NEED to know. ?You don't have to grade him compared to another 25 kids, and you don't even have to report to his parents every six or nine weeks! ? There might be lulls in his progress instead of a sharp, steady curve. It sounds like he's having fun with it, and as long as he sees it as something desireable and joyful, however it comes will be good. Sandra |
toddler diet [previously called (unknown)]
I
As far as the junk food; toddlers need surprisingly little food volume and variety isn't a concern yet. As long as he's not underweight (if he is, this is a medical issue instead) then I would offer a selection of foods and stand back. If a baby's on the low end of the scale, don't forget the scale belongs to the AMA and has to do with statistics, rather than with the health or realities of individual humans. ?There can't be an average without some people at the extremes, and some are naturally at the extremes from genetics, and they are at their OWN "normal" (midrange for their own body's development, as their body has no idea about other organisms of the same age). I'm guessing by "underweight" maybe the writer meant unhealthily scrawny or dangerously thin. ? Holly seems scrawny to me. ?She always has. ?But she's strong and active and so I just don't worry about her bones showing. ?I'm sure it will pass sooner than she'd like it to (given the prevailing prejudices in the land in which she lives). Sandra |
Re: (unknown)
Might it give him the space to try Have you tried the happy-face method? ?(Pancakes in artsy shapes, with Mickey-Mouse ears; open-faced cheese sandwiches with design with different colored cheeses?) Have you gone to the store hunting for JUST special, new foods he might like? -=-Yesterday he ate a bowl of rice crispies with milk and then nothing else! He is still nursing so that eases my fear somewhat. -=- We used to make (still do, but the concept started then, after a zoo trip) "monkey platters" for the kids. ?Maraschino (sp?) cherries, little pieces of pineapple (there is some now shaped like moons and stars), tiny crackers, like Goldfish or I forget the little square orange ones), little squares of cheese (smaller than normal), grapes... ?Give them toothpicks to eat the stuff with, if they're old enough to be safe with toothpicks. -=-statement regarding kids that through tantrums to get what they want in stores . . . ?how does one change it? How does one set the limit yet still maintain respect and teh child autonomy?-=- In-store strategies: ?Interact with the child more instead of leaving the store to entertain him. ??Carry him so his head is near yours, or have him in the cart facing you, and keep up a conversation about things other than the store, or talk to him about what you're buying and why if it's the grocery store. Go to a checkout with boring stuff on the sides if they have one--lots of stores do, just because kids are unlikely to beg for emery boards and razors and lighters and stuff. Let him hold something interesting that you're buying, something unbreakable but colorful and fun. Praise him for being helpful. ?Tell him it's fun to go with him so you have someone to talk to. ?Make him feel a help instead of a hindrance. If he's older and in the habit of begging and crying, talk about it being stressful, and that you don't WANT to wish to be alone, but that the crying makes it no fun for you to go to the store. ??He'll forget, and he'll lapse, but you can say "I don't want you to come if you're going to cry." ?Then don't consider it a binding contract if he's little and fails to maintain himself. ?? Sometimes get him cool things when he doesn't ask for them, and tell him it's because he was so good in the store. ?Or just say you thought he might really like that, and surprise him. If my husband shamed me when we went shopping and complained about taking me when we got home, I'd want loot to show for my mental anguish. ?Some families are not very nice to their kids in/around/after stores, in my experience. ? So not knowing the particulars of the situation and not being around for the prior discussion where it first took place, there are some ideas of mine. Sandra |
the elusive exchange rate of non-monetary values
In a message dated 11/27/01 2:04:42 AM Mountain Standard Time, vegan4planet@... writes:
. I really don't Makana, It's okay if things get stirred up. ?I think poking people where they're comfortable is a productive use of a list. ??We don't all have to be encouraging of everything anyone else comes up with. I was thinking about the chess analogy, and the points worked as an analogy really well, as far as immediate expenditure, but I had some other thoughts. ?That kind of money isn't spent on a beginning chess player, only a small percentage of the best. ?Gamers have to lay out maybe $25 just to get in the game sometimes. ?(Unless they hang out with a group of people who each can contribute a dozen cards to design them a deck, which does happen for sure.) ? And the chess analogy looked back upon ten years later will have less detritus than years of CCG (collectible card game) or miniatures gaming. ?On the other other hand, that detritus does sell on e-bay. My kids used to love getting new Pogs. ?It gave them joy, frenzied delight, visions of electric sugarplums. ?Now there are ziploc bags of pogs in boxes here and there. ?Someday some younger kid not yet born now is going to have a GREAT few hours going through those, claiming the best as a new treasure, putting most back in the bags as weird old stuff, and a few will probably make it a hundred years into the future to be oddities in some future person's collection of antiques. ? How evil is that? ? It is odd, but it's not immoral. I was indignant when I was in college and a friend from a wealthy family bought her mother a miniature flyswatter (dollhouse size) for $5. ?I was from a poor family, and in the early 1970's $5 was, for me, a lot of money. ??My friend defended the purchase, saying it was art, and that her mom would really appreciate it. I later saw her mom's dollhouse, and it was marvelous, funky, glorious, and will someday be in a museum for thousands to see. ?I no longer begrudged her the fine-wire piece of flyswatter art. ?Unfortunately, it had never been found at Christmas. ?It was wrapped up miniaturely and fastened to another package and was lost without her mom ever having seen it. ? So was that a loss of $5 or a good lesson for me? ?Here I am 27 years later still thinking about it. Sandra |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges (was Re: Expensive Ga...
In a message dated 11/26/2001 11:06:40 PM Pacific Standard Time, crma@... writes:
I would argue that all of these including gaming can have value. ?The And, if you've ever watched the kids in the game store, each with the tape measure out, it even IS partly physical -- there is manual dexterity involved as well as hand-eye coordination. Probably those who have it don't appreciate it - but it is something that is great for a 12 yo boy to be developing - especially those who don't yet write comfortably. I'd sure rather have them developing that sense of distance and hand-eye coordination now, then wait until they're behind the wheel of their first car, for example! Not that, in my mind, this kind of argument is needed to justify playing the games -- just that they are fun and satisfying to the kid is enough for me, really. I mean, isn't a lot of our own lives a search for things to do that satisfy us? Sheesh - why do we feel anxious when our kids FIND such things? --pam |
Re: fantasy gaming vs real challenges
In a message dated 11/27/01 1:04:01 AM, SandraDodd@... writes:
<< -=-This is way out there, but I feel like people can never get enough of (be satisfied by) something that isn't really satisfying. -=- It seems to be the nature of humans to feel unsatisfied, to want something more, better, different, and new. >> Satisfaction is having a need met. It can also be lesson learned, job well done, confirmation of a path taken. It can be the feeling of a moment's reflection, or an overview. To say that something isn't really satisfying seems to demand more of the feeling than is necessarily appropriate. To imply that unless imbued with altruism, the feeling is selfish and of lower quality. Nick (my 12 year old) seems to find real satisfaction in playing D&D. Go figure. What he gets out of it: He has characters he imbues with characteristics and personality -- he controls their actions but not their fate. He learns to deal with adversity and disappointment, to come up with solutions to unexpected challenges. He experiments with responses which have no real life consequences, in the company of friends. He gets to make mistakes and try again, without hurting someone "real". He and his friends play for hours at a time -- they argue and negotiate, debate the merits of a over b -- these are real skills which will in future serve them well. He's also the Dungeon Master (the person who develops the story for a group of gamers) for a weekly online group. He started this group -- and has members ranging from 15 to 30 years in age. His ability to plan a quest in advance, to decide what problems the groups will face, which monsters they will encounter, what pitfalls will spring up -- amazes and pleases me. I value his imagination and ability to guide and inspire others. Childhood is short. I know there's a mindset which says that we denigrate childhood by assuming it wants no altruism, to make no real difference in the world. That to imply by allowing children to stay at home or in school, "wait until you're older to make a real difference" invalidates the child as a whole and capable person. Eh. When I was in seventh grade, as a class, we collected money for food, packaged it up, and drove an hour and a half to a small town, and delivered food packages to families whose fathers were in jail. I felt both awkward and self-righteous -- awkward because some families seemed uncomfortable with us trooping into their house with boxes of food, and self-righteous because some famiies lived in "nice" houses and how was it they needed this support? I did a supportive action, without having the perspective to really understand it. I got the underlying emotions, without awareness of what their situations really were. That same year, we spent some time playing with children at a penitentiary, during visiting hours for families, so husbands and wives could talk without interruption. There was resentment and hostility swirling around which now, I can certainly understand. But then, it was confusing and alarming. There are children who've done amazing things with volunteer efforts. There are adults as well. But not all adults do. Not all children do. Such is life. I want to give my kids time to grow up internally, at their pace, in a supportive environment geared to who they are. I contribute to causes which are important to me -- and if my kids decided they wanted to participate in a cause, I'd support that too. But I'm not going to nudge them into it as something which they should be doing now, to be real. There are gives and gets, as in all things. Sharon |
Toddler Eating
What follows is my opinion, which is all I feel qualified to give :^) It may
not be right for your world, but it works in mine, so I thought I'd share. Elissa writes: Also, the eating issue (I really wish S was here to answer this one) My twotry other healthier foods and realize he likes them? I don't want to be a foodHe Congratulations! You have a healthy toddler! Despite our best efforts to understand them, they can apparently either devour entire houses or live like birds on the tiniest morsels, or both, on alternating days :^) First of all, don't worry. If he is healthy otherwise, there is no reason to fear. He won't starve himself. My mom is a nutritionist, and she assures me that I didn't grow up dead, despite being a non-eating toddler. Don't worry about getting that "balanced diet" all in one day -- work it out over the week, and you'll see he's doing pretty well. Believe me, he could be doing a lot worse than rice crispies and milk. And if he likes raisin bran, that's all the better (more iron & fiber)! As for junk food, rid the house of candy and other empty calories; offer enriched substitutes. Does he like muffins? Great! Make yours extra-good by adding in pureed butternut squash or pumpkin or carrots or zucchini to spike the vitamins. Powdered milk, whole wheat flour, bran, these are also great add-ins. If you are meat-eaters, powdered milk and shredded veggies added to meatloaf ups calcium, protein and vitamins. There are recipes floating around out there for healthy versions of a lot of "forbidden" things (cakes, cookies, etc.) that are fabulous. Write me if you are looking for something in particular and can't find it on the web. (Barring allergies or other food restrictions) apple, orange or pear slices (etc.) can be dipped in yogurt, (natural) peanut butter or pureed OTHER fruit. A wonderful playdough can be made from peanut butter, honey and powdered milk. It's still a sweet, but you can control the level of honey. French fries can be made from sweet potatoes and baked in the oven! These have more vitamins and are truly yummy. Sometimes it's a matter of presentation: toddlers who won't touch carrots or other veggies when they are whole will sometimes happily wolf them down when you shred them and make a pile of "hay." Those who won't eat sliced cheese might be very happy with string cheese. Leaving beans whole and eating them like french fries can be fun. Dehydrated foods can be fun -- making your own fruit leather can be something they can help with (stirring and measuring), and can be a great alternative to candy or commercial "fruit" leather (although I hear my mom's voice in my head still, "whole fruits are better than dried or juices") One of the things I've noticed about my children-as-toddlers is that they are very charmed by mini versions of anythings, mini-pancakes (which you've enriched with whole wheat, powdered milk and fruit or pumpkin, etc., and which my daughter thinks are better than cookies), mini-meatloaves (just enough for one toddler), mini-casseroles baked in their own little dish (muffin or custard cups work well for both of the previous), mini-pastas, etc. When you do try new foods out, do them with a minimum of flourish or pressure (but you already knew that). The only rule in our house is that you must taste it once before leaving it alone on the plate (no yelling of YUCK, please!). I only introduce one new food at a time. If it is rejected, I rotate that one out for a while, but try it again a month or so later. Typically, if you don't make a big deal about it, neither will they, and exposure to a wide variety of foods will eventually yield results in their willingness to try new ones. But it will not cure the bird appetite. For that, I just made a mantra of my mom's words (He will not starve himself he will not starve himself he will not starve himself He'll eat when he's ready he'll eat when he's ready...) :^) Some folks give a multi-vitamin and others don't. Either way, just relax and try not to...worry :^) If he's truly hungry, he'll let you know, and if he's running around and active, that hungry time WILL eventually happen :^) Whoops--just noticed how long this got, sorry! Hope it helps. All the discussion so far on other topics has been very interesting and helpful to me. I'm really glad to be here :^) Peace, Wynn |
to navigate to use esc to dismiss