Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
Search
Some test results using a NanoVNA
I recently updated my blog with two posts showing the measuement results I have obtained using a NanoVNA.
one shows the response of a multiband HF antenna. The latest one shows the response of a step attenuator I recently built. I must say that I am more than pleased with the results I have been able to obtain with such an inexpensive instrument. It has been interesting following some of the discussions about calibration and the math involved with the VNA, but I am more interested in what people are using it for real world applications. -- DuWayne? KV4QB |
Bob Albert
I too have been enjoying the amazing capabilities of this little jewel.? I now find that I can measure most parameters of passive components and networks with excellent accuracy.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I can measurecapacitanceESRESLinductanceresistancedelayphase angleSWRimpedanceself resonant frequencyQcrystal parameterscoaxial cable parameters:?characteristic impedance?electrical length?propagation constant?capacitance?inductance?lossesconnector capacitanceinductance of wiresfilter parameters:?pass band?stop band?matching impedanceantenna parameters:?SWR?resonant frequency?bandwidth?spurious resonances?impedance?line lengthspectrum analysis, sort ofCW frequency Probably more, as I haven't exhausted the possibilities yet. Most measurements come within a percent or two of that reported by my expensive bridges.? When there is discrepancy, I often can trace it to the use of a different test frequency.? Testing electrolytic capacitors isn't too satisfactory, as they are pretty much worthless at any frequency the nanoVNA uses.? However the readings can be useful, showing how important it is to bypass an electrolytic capacitor for high frequency. I have two nanoVNAs just to make sure I can still use one if the other breaks.? My old fashioned fancy expensive boat anchor VNAs are still handy for frequencies beyond the nano's capabilities. Anyone with questions about how to set it up to measure any of this, feel free to ask. Bob K6DDX On Monday, December 16, 2019, 02:07:34 PM PST, DuWayne Schmidlkofer <duwayne@...> wrote:
I recently updated my blog with two posts showing the measuement results I have obtained using a NanoVNA. one shows the response of a multiband HF antenna.? The latest one shows the response of a step attenuator I recently built. I must say that I am more than pleased with the results I have been able to obtain with such an inexpensive instrument. It has been interesting following some of the discussions about calibration and the math involved with the VNA, but I am more interested in what people are using? it for real world applications. -- DuWayne? KV4QB |
Bob Albert
My message was gargled beyond recognition by whatever stupid software handled it.? <sigh>
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Bob On Monday, December 16, 2019, 03:30:53 PM PST, Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343@...> wrote:
I too have been enjoying the amazing capabilities of this little jewel.? I now find that I can measure most parameters of passive components and networks with excellent accuracy. I can measurecapacitanceESRESLinductanceresistancedelayphase angleSWRimpedanceself resonant frequencyQcrystal parameterscoaxial cable parameters:?characteristic impedance?electrical length?propagation constant?capacitance?inductance?lossesconnector capacitanceinductance of wiresfilter parameters:?pass band?stop band?matching impedanceantenna parameters:?SWR?resonant frequency?bandwidth?spurious resonances?impedance?line lengthspectrum analysis, sort ofCW frequency Probably more, as I haven't exhausted the possibilities yet. Most measurements come within a percent or two of that reported by my expensive bridges.? When there is discrepancy, I often can trace it to the use of a different test frequency.? Testing electrolytic capacitors isn't too satisfactory, as they are pretty much worthless at any frequency the nanoVNA uses.? However the readings can be useful, showing how important it is to bypass an electrolytic capacitor for high frequency. I have two nanoVNAs just to make sure I can still use one if the other breaks.? My old fashioned fancy expensive boat anchor VNAs are still handy for frequencies beyond the nano's capabilities. Anyone with questions about how to set it up to measure any of this, feel free to ask. Bob K6DDX ? ? On Monday, December 16, 2019, 02:07:34 PM PST, DuWayne Schmidlkofer <duwayne@...> wrote: I recently updated my blog with two posts showing the measuement results I have obtained using a NanoVNA. one shows the response of a multiband HF antenna.? The latest one shows the response of a step attenuator I recently built. I must say that I am more than pleased with the results I have been able to obtain with such an inexpensive instrument. It has been interesting following some of the discussions about calibration and the math involved with the VNA, but I am more interested in what people are using? it for real world applications. -- DuWayne? KV4QB |
Martin
So how do you measure inductance using it?
Could you tune a trap with it? How? Thanks. Martin K0BXB On Mon, Dec 16, 2019, 5:30 PM Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343= [email protected]> wrote: I too have been enjoying the amazing capabilities of this little jewel. |
Martin
What's needed to connect my NanoVNA- to my Android phone to use the
NanoVNA- Webb app? Just a usbc to usbc cable? Martin K0BXB On Tue, Dec 17, 2019, 5:35 AM Martin via Groups.Io <huyettmeh= [email protected]> wrote: So how do you measure inductance using it? |
What's needed to connect my NanoVNA- to my Android phone to use the/g/nanovna-users/message/4970 |
Bob Albert
How to measure inductance?? Very simple.? First, you make up an adapter so you can connect the unknown to the nano S0.
Calibrate the nano.? The next step depends on the inductance.? Select a frequency appropriate to the part, 50 kHz for low frequency parts and up into the high frequencies for rf chokes and into the VHF and UHF for straight pieces of wire, etc.? Since you can't go below 50 kHz that limits how large an inductor you can measure. Select Smith chart for display.? Read inductance off the screen.? You can read the resistance and compute the Q.? If the inductance is very small, short the leads and take a reading, which you subtract from the final reading. With the leads shorted, the Smith chart should have a dot at the left edge.? With the leads open, at the right edge.? If the dot is not at the edge it indicates a low Q. As a reality check, open up the span to a reasonable frequency range and move the marker over the range.? The inductance should remain relatively constant.? If you open up the frequency range the chart shows a circle.? At some point the circle intersects the horizontal axis at the self resonant frequency.? With high Q you need to keep the span narrow, as the resonanct frequency can elude measurement since it's very sharp. The same procedure works for other components.? For cables, it will show electrical length.? The way you measure that is to adjust the frequency so that the Smith circle, for an open end coax, starts at the right and sweeps down and around up to the left.? Where it reaches the center line on the left is the frequency where the coax is one quarter wave long.? The deviation from the outside circle indicates loss. Then you put a small pot as a termination for the open coax and adjust it until the Smith trace shrinks to a dot in the center.? At that point, measure the pot with an Ohmmeter and it will be the characteristic impedance. This inexpensive device is not a toy.? It's a sophisticated, well designed piece of first rate test equipment.? No ham with tools should be without one. Each time I use mine I learn new ways to use it.? You can measure diode capacitance and, with care, can plot a curve of capacitance vs bias to characterize it as a voltage variable capacitor to use in a PLL or tuning network.? Just don't apply dc to the vna port.? Or any voltage.? It has its own generator, very accurate.? You can measure transistor and tube capacitances as well.? Or connectors. If you connect nothing to the nano it will show a residual reading, sometimes into the femtofarads (one femtofarad is a thousandth of a picofarad).? I never measured a femtofarad before. I measure crystals this way.? This is tricky, as crystals have very high Q and you need to keep the span very tiny.? You need to know the frequency, which is generally marked on the crystal.? Set the nano as that number for center and a small span, say a few kHz.? The crystal frequency will show at the left edge but not on a circle due to the lack of frequency resolution.? Keep narrowing the span until you can read frequency as close as you like, although the resolution isn't all that small. When measuring capacitors the ESR is indicated on the screen.? To measure ESL you measure the self resonant frequency (curve intersecting horizontal line) and compute it from the classic formula.? Or go to a somewhat higher frequency and read the screen.? Remember that the reading is based on a simulation of the part as a resistance in series with a reactance. You measure the distributed capacitance and ESL of a resistor the same way.? With care you can get readings that are very accurate.? The standard used for measuring all of this is the 50 Ohm load you use during calibration so that needs to be very good for precise readings.? My resistor readings are within about 1% of what my GR bridge and HP 3456A show. I know the question was how to measure inductance but I got carried away. Questions? Bob K6DDX On Tuesday, December 17, 2019, 04:59:21 AM PST, Oristo <ormpoa@...> wrote: > What's needed to connect my NanoVNA- to my Android phone to use the NanoVNA- Webb app? Just a usbc to usbc cable?/g/nanovna-users/message/4970 |
Bob Albert
One addendum regarding inductance.? I did mention that 50 kHz as a low limit prevents measurement of large inductances.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
I just measured a few and got good results up to around 50 mH.? My inductance stock doesn't have specially made parts so the higher inductances have very low self resonat frequencies.? Measuring the bigger ones gives an inductance reading that is too small, since the distributed capacitance begins to shunt the inductance. So for L up to a few dozen millihenries it's usable but not terribly accurate.? Down to the microhenries and below it's good.? Inductance of a straight wire is easily measured if the test fixture can accommodate it.? Shorting the leads gives a residual reading you can subtract but it's not that simple, as we are dealing with magnetic fields and any change in position messes it up. The same is true for capacitances below several dozen picofarads. Bob On Tuesday, December 17, 2019, 10:12:15 AM PST, Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343@...> wrote:
How to measure inductance?? Very simple.? First, you make up an adapter so you can connect the unknown to the nano S0. Calibrate the nano.? The next step depends on the inductance.? Select a frequency appropriate to the part, 50 kHz for low frequency parts and up into the high frequencies for rf chokes and into the VHF and UHF for straight pieces of wire, etc.? Since you can't go below 50 kHz that limits how large an inductor you can measure. Select Smith chart for display.? Read inductance off the screen.? You can read the resistance and compute the Q.? If the inductance is very small, short the leads and take a reading, which you subtract from the final reading. With the leads shorted, the Smith chart should have a dot at the left edge.? With the leads open, at the right edge.? If the dot is not at the edge it indicates a low Q. As a reality check, open up the span to a reasonable frequency range and move the marker over the range.? The inductance should remain relatively constant.? If you open up the frequency range the chart shows a circle.? At some point the circle intersects the horizontal axis at the self resonant frequency.? With high Q you need to keep the span narrow, as the resonanct frequency can elude measurement since it's very sharp. The same procedure works for other components.? For cables, it will show electrical length.? The way you measure that is to adjust the frequency so that the Smith circle, for an open end coax, starts at the right and sweeps down and around up to the left.? Where it reaches the center line on the left is the frequency where the coax is one quarter wave long.? The deviation from the outside circle indicates loss. Then you put a small pot as a termination for the open coax and adjust it until the Smith trace shrinks to a dot in the center.? At that point, measure the pot with an Ohmmeter and it will be the characteristic impedance. This inexpensive device is not a toy.? It's a sophisticated, well designed piece of first rate test equipment.? No ham with tools should be without one. Each time I use mine I learn new ways to use it.? You can measure diode capacitance and, with care, can plot a curve of capacitance vs bias to characterize it as a voltage variable capacitor to use in a PLL or tuning network.? Just don't apply dc to the vna port.? Or any voltage.? It has its own generator, very accurate.? You can measure transistor and tube capacitances as well.? Or connectors. If you connect nothing to the nano it will show a residual reading, sometimes into the femtofarads (one femtofarad is a thousandth of a picofarad).? I never measured a femtofarad before. I measure crystals this way.? This is tricky, as crystals have very high Q and you need to keep the span very tiny.? You need to know the frequency, which is generally marked on the crystal.? Set the nano as that number for center and a small span, say a few kHz.? The crystal frequency will show at the left edge but not on a circle due to the lack of frequency resolution.? Keep narrowing the span until you can read frequency as close as you like, although the resolution isn't all that small. When measuring capacitors the ESR is indicated on the screen.? To measure ESL you measure the self resonant frequency (curve intersecting horizontal line) and compute it from the classic formula.? Or go to a somewhat higher frequency and read the screen.? Remember that the reading is based on a simulation of the part as a resistance in series with a reactance. You measure the distributed capacitance and ESL of a resistor the same way.? With care you can get readings that are very accurate.? The standard used for measuring all of this is the 50 Ohm load you use during calibration so that needs to be very good for precise readings.? My resistor readings are within about 1% of what my GR bridge and HP 3456A show. I know the question was how to measure inductance but I got carried away. Questions? Bob K6DDX ? ? On Tuesday, December 17, 2019, 04:59:21 AM PST, Oristo <ormpoa@...> wrote: > What's needed to connect my NanoVNA- to my Android phone to use the NanoVNA- Webb app? Just a usbc to usbc cable?/g/nanovna-users/message/4970 |
Martin
Thanks Bob. I'll give it a go.
Martin K0BXB On Tue, Dec 17, 2019, 12:12 PM Bob Albert via Groups.Io <bob91343= [email protected]> wrote: How to measure inductance? Very simple. First, you make up an adapter |
On Tue, Dec 17, 2019 at 11:46 AM, Bob Albert wrote:
Very good Bob... in your post above... Measuring the bigger ones gives an inductance reading that is too small, sinceHowever, the result of distributive C for an inductor which is one appropriate model, shunt C, leads to an inductor value which INCREASES as we approach SRF. The arithmetic for this is; Xt= jwL/(1-w^2LC) where w is radian frequency and Xt is the total reactance for this case. As w^2 approaches 1/(LC), Xt goes through the roof. A larger apparent L. Alan |
Bob Albert
You are correct Alan, I was too hasty in my enthusiasm.? And when the result is pure resistance there is resonance.? At frequencies above self resonance an inductor acts as a capacitor.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Which underscores my comment that this is not only a measuring instrument but also a learning tool. Watching values change with frequency and termination is fascinating.? Try connecting a coil and capacitor to the nano and observe how frequency changes with capacitance.? Or as you squeeze the coil turns.? See how Q changes. I used to be intimidated by the Smith chart but now its mysteries have unraveled themselves.? Thanks to Joseph Smith for devising it in the late 1930s. Perceptive readers may have noted my omission of the S1 port, which can be used to see filter response.? If that never gets used, the remaining functions still offer better bang for the buck than any other piece of gear I have found, short of a freebie.? Did I mention that the nano is also a CW and sweep generator?? Output fixed in the range of -10 dBm, 0.1 mW.? Frequency accuracy rated at 2 ppm or so; mine more accurate than that. Bob K6DDX On Tuesday, December 17, 2019, 01:58:30 PM PST, alan victor <avictor73@...> wrote:
On Tue, Dec 17, 2019 at 11:46 AM, Bob Albert wrote: Very good Bob... in your post above... Measuring the bigger ones gives an inductance reading that is too small, sinceHowever, the result of distributive C for an inductor which is one appropriate model, shunt C, leads to an inductor value which INCREASES as we approach SRF. The arithmetic for this is; Xt= jwL/(1-w^2LC) where w is radian frequency and Xt is the total reactance for this case. As w^2? approaches 1/(LC), Xt goes through the roof. A larger apparent L. Alan |
to navigate to use esc to dismiss