Keyboard Shortcuts
ctrl + shift + ? :
Show all keyboard shortcuts
ctrl + g :
Navigate to a group
ctrl + shift + f :
Find
ctrl + / :
Quick actions
esc to dismiss
Likes
- Nanovna-Users
- Messages
Search
Re: USB vs no USB readings Plots change...
On Sun, Aug 27, 2023 at 09:56 PM, Mark KQ4EKK wrote:
It sounds as if your measurement system is not sufficiently decoupling the test articles, so the test system is becoming part of the measurement; this happens often when measuring antennas. Perhaps if you shared a diagram of your test system it would help us to understand what is going on. Since you are testing ununs, it is possible that one of your measurement ports has a floating shield connection or similar, which picks up a ground (sorta) when the USB cable is plugged in. 73, Don N2VGU |
Re: USB vs no USB readings Plots change...
Hello
I just did a test on mine which is a NanoVNA-F [v1.0.5] Is it real? a clone ? I bought it in February 2021 : Moligh doll Vector Network Analyzer NanoVNA-F HF VHF UHF UV VNA Antenna Analyzer 10KHz-1.5GHz 4.3 Inch Press Screen Sold by : Amazon hui zhou shi hong qing dian zi you xian gong si hui yang qu dan shui kai cheng da dao bei 17 hao er lou si shi qi ka wei hui zhou shi, GUANG DONG SHENG, 516211 CN ----------------------- It was connected to a 5 m coaxial cable with a line cap "in the air" at the end (I calibrated before at the end of the cable). When I plugged the USB plug into my PC, without launching nanaovna-saver, the figure displayed did not change; the NanoVNA is in permanent scanning (relaxed). I tried with a real antenna, at the end of an additional 10 m cable but earthed at the bottom; same, nothing changed. On the other hand, if when I plug in the USB plug nothing happens, when I unplug the plug, it's like when I turn on the NanoVNA, with the home page displayed briefly. The same figure reappears on the screen as before unplugging. 73 -- F1AMM Fran?ois |
Re: USB vs no USB readings Plots change...
I¡¯ve seen similar as well. Oftentimes I don¡¯t take the time to test with multiple configurations but occasionally I¡¯ve noticed where either the Smith chart trace ¡°doesn¡¯t look right¡± or the SWR plot, and that leads me to a bad connector, etcetera. Even holding the NanoVNA or having a laptop too close changed things, so not too surprised that adding a USB cable had that effect. It¡¯s certainly not a laboratory-grade instrument but it does very well for what it costs¡. Does recalibrating help at all? That would be my first instinct but I¡¯m curious to try it myself now.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
73, Greg KN7GIG "Silence is golden. Duct tape is silver." On Aug 27, 2023, at 21:56, Mark KQ4EKK <kq4ekk+groups@...> wrote: |
USB vs no USB readings Plots change...
Mark KQ4EKK
I am building different Un:Uns using different wiring schemes and caps. While testing a config, I noticed that my battery was down to one bar and I did not have the USB cable plugged in at the time. I was not keeping records at the time, just quick tests. So I did not have my nanovna H4 4.3 plugged in, not using Nanovna-App at the time. I just plugged it in and saw the plot change on the nano display. I went HMMMM. was i touching something? did I move something? No.
I started testing by unplugging the usb, and my original plot came back. Then I plugged it back in and back to same "changed" plot. Repeatable and always the same places the changed occurred. Thought, maybe my cable is bad. Nope tried 3 different higher quality cables and exact same results. Did the same test on PC directly and not on the usb expansion bar (maybe it introduces the problem). Nope, same plot changes on pc directly to nanovna with all 3 cables. OK, maybe some ferrites will help. Put on 2 Fair-rite type 31 beads (purchased from Mouser, not amazon or ebay!), same changes. ok remove pc from the equation... I tested on a laptop with battery only, no outside electricity. Desktop on laptop has no apps open (nanovna-app) or anything. Simply plugging in the usb cable changes the plot on the nanovna, not the same but very similar change to the pc plugged in change. I also let the nanovna FULLY charge while turned off and then tested again. Simply plugging into an external power source via the usb is causing the issue. Has anyone seen this before? Do you think that the battery charging circuit in the vna is causing the issue (before I examine this further)? Some details about the nanovna. Nanovna H4. HW version 4.3_MS It was purchased via Amazon from the AURSINC store, which was listed on the nanovna.com site as a authentic seller. I have looked inside the unit and it is clean and well manufactured. Clean solder points and the unit arrived in the official box with all parts. I believe this to be an authentic unit and not clone. The errors are shown across the whole spectrum but are very low at low frequencies and grow exponentially higher with higher frequencies. I am doing a S21 logmag plot from 1MHz to 30MHz. There also seems to be large shift (jump down) around 15MHz. Any thoughts would be welcomed. Thanks in advance, Mark |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
QUOTE: Cars are mobile noise generators
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Especially Fords. Dave - W?LEV On Sun, Aug 27, 2023 at 9:53?PM Rick Murphy <k1mu.nospam@...> wrote:
The AM radio in my car works just fine. Chevy BoltEV.-- *Dave - W?LEV* --
Dave - W?LEV |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
The AM radio in my car works just fine. Chevy BoltEV.
How short our memories are - does nobody else remember "alternator noise"? Cars are mobile noise generators. 73, -Rick On Sat, Aug 26, 2023 at 9:47?PM N7RWB Craig Cherry via groups.io <craig.cherry@...> wrote: Ken, looking through FCC part 15 rules on emissions, I don¡¯t see any-- Rick Murphy, D. Sc., CISSP-ISSAP, K1MU/4, Annandale VA USA |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
Don't waste your time writing to the FCC.? About 20 years ago, Chairman Reed Hundt declared that interference didn't exist.? He said he went outside at lunch time and while using his cell phone, he didn't hear any.? Then he started shutting down field offices. The FCC also is convinced that the marketplace will resolve such questions.? It's a lot more accurate to say that there is a "marketplace effect" rather than a marketplace solution.? If you don't have enough complainants to cause the vendor to lose revenue, there is no effect.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
How do I know about this?? I worked at the FCC Saint Paul Field Office for over 30 years.? And I resolved many interference problems over 30 years.? I never ceased to be amazed that so many items can generate an RF signal. Frank Evans K0AM Ellsworth WI On 8/27/2023 2:41 PM, Glenn Little wrote:
Document the issues. |
High Frequency Circuit Design TEXTS for SALE
High Frequency Circuit Design, Hardy, 360 pages
New Condition Excellent and Easy Read and Comprehend! A duplicate from my library¡ $15.00 plus media shipped ATC/ AVX Capacitor Handbook,,, Everything on RF Ceramic Caps Loads of Application Guides FREE¡ Will bundle with the Text¡ Total $20.00 FOR ALL. PM ME OFF LIST IF INTERESTED, THANKS, |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
Document the issues.
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
Send a copy to the FCC. If no action is taken, take the vehicle to the Green bank observatory and park it for a while. That should get some attention. Glenn On 8/27/2023 2:21 PM, Dragan Milivojevic wrote:
Document your findings in a blog post and spread the word? --
----------------------------------------------------------------------- Glenn Little ARRL Technical Specialist QCWA LM 28417 Amateur Callsign: WB4UIVwb4uiv@... AMSAT LM 2178 QTH: Goose Creek, SC USA (EM92xx) USSVI, FRA, NRA-LM ARRL TAPR "It is not the class of license that the Amateur holds but the class of the Amateur that holds the license" |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
Document your findings in a blog post and spread the word?
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
They will do nothing without media exposure. On Sun, 27 Aug 2023 at 19:22, W0LEV <davearea51a@...> wrote:
|
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
I don't like to be the bearer of bad news, but the dealership has no idea
what RFI is. They know the words and there is a problem with some Jeep models, but that's as far as they go. Experience follows: While somewhat of an esoteric problem with RFI: the "Water Hole" surrounding 1420.405751 MHz. This is the emission line of celestial and deep space hydrogen designated by HI. The Water Hole is protected spectrum by international agreement, including the US. Well,......., read on. We have a 2018 Jeep JL Rubicon. It, of course, includes the capability of serving as a hotspot for the internet and making cell phone calls. As such, it contains a cell modem as part of the electronics behind the video display in the dash. That modem operates at nominally 700 MHz (I've easily detected its fundamental frequency output on the spectrum analyzer) . The second harmonic screams out of the assembly and blankets the hydrogen line such that I can not do radio astronomy on that frequency. It ceases "looking for mommie" - finding a cell tower as we have no cell coverage at home - after sitting untraveled for 3 or 4 days. Does it track my travels? Absolutely yes, but that's a different problem. I have four times contacted the local dealership where we bought the vehicle. They have absolutely no inkling of what I'm talking about other than recognizing the term "Radio Frequency Interference". I've sent Jeep in Toledo - their engineering department - three letters documenting, screen grabs, the interference both as captured on the spectrum analyzer of the second harmonic of the cell modem and in the time domain from my receiver as captured on the laptop at 1420 MHz (after some downconversion and detection). There has been absolutely no response from them, either, other than a form email "thanking me for my interest in Jeep".........which we already own. Thanks, but no thanks! Frustrated......? Yes.......! There are instructions online on disabling the cell modem, but since we camp off-grid in many...many locations which do not have any cell coverage or amateur repeaters, I'm reluctant to do so. In addition, it involves literally taking the whole dash apart which I'm not into attempting. All I can communicate is, "good luck"........and, there really is no such thing as "luck". YMMV......? Dave - W?LEV On Sun, Aug 27, 2023 at 5:22?PM W0LEV via groups.io <davearea51a= [email protected]> wrote: I don't like to be the bearer of bad news, but the dealership has no idea-- *Dave - W?LEV* -- Dave - W?LEV |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
I don't like to be the bearer of bad news, but the dealership has no idea
what RFI is. They know the words and there is a problem with some Jeep models, but that's as far as they go. Experience follows: While somewhat of an esoteric problem with RFI: the "Water Hole" surrounding 1420.405751 MHz. This is the emission line of celestial and deep space hydrogen designated by HI. The Water Hole is protected spectrum by international agreement, including the US. Well,......., read on. We have a 2018 Jeep JL Rubicon. It, of course, includes the capability of serving as a hotspot for the internet and making cell phone calls. As such, it contains a cell modem as part of the electronics behind the video display in the dash. That modem operates at nominally 700 MHz (I've easily detected its fundamental frequency output on the spectrum analyzer) . The second harmonic screams out of the assembly and blankets the hydrogen line such that I can not do radio astronomy on that frequency. It ceases "looking for mommie" - finding a cell tower as we have no cell coverage at home - after sitting untraveled for 3 or 4 days. Does it track my travels? Absolutely yes, but that's a different problem. I have four times contacted the local dealership where we bought the vehicle. They have absolutely no inkling of what I'm talking about other than recognizing the term "Radio Frequency Interference". I've sent Jeep in Toledo - their engineering department - three letters documenting, screen grabs, the interference both as captured on the spectrum analyzer of the second harmonic of the cell modem and in the time domain from my receiver as captured on the laptop at 1420 MHz (after some downconversion and detection). There has been absolutely no response from them, either, other than a form email "thanking me for my interest in Jeep".........which we already own. Thanks, but no thanks! Frustrated......? Yes.......! There are instructions online on disabling the cell modem, but since we camp off-grid in many...many locations which do not have any cell coverage or amateur repeaters, I'm reluctant to do so. In addition, it involves literally taking the whole dash apart which I'm not into attempting. All I can communicate is, "good luck"........and, there really is no such thing as "luck". YMMV......? Dave - W?LEV On Sat, Aug 26, 2023 at 11:49?PM Glenn Little <glennmaillist@...> wrote: Take it back to the dealer and insist that they fix the problem.-- *Dave - W?LEV* -- Dave - W?LEV |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
On 27/08/2023 03:44, fbray@... wrote:
Unfortunately I can't see any photos. Maybe it's just me or maybe they need to be posted to the photos section? I don't know how the group is set up.Same here - they showed a little squares, a few pixels wide, and both appeared the same way and to have the same content. I use e-mail to access the group. Cheers, David -- SatSignal Software - Quality software for you Web: Email: david-taylor@... Twitter: @gm8arv |
Re: Not available at Ali Express / Zeenko
I have used Ali many times over the years, in particular Zeenko. I have never used my card but always PayPal and usually by messaging the young lady, whose name escapes me. She has always produced a Pp invoice and products have always been on point.
Just my personal experience but may help you. -- It is better to help than hinder and judge. Garry M0MGP....GB6WLB (SES).....GB6NT? (SES) M5C Contest Group |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
Craig-
My opinion- Electric vehicles are most likely considered an incidental radiator. They are exempted under ¡ì15.103 (a) provided harmful interference is not created under ¡ì15.3 (m) Essential question is if interference to broadcast stations is considered harmful interference as defined in ¡ì 15.3 (m) |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
Unfortunately I can't see any photos. Maybe it's just me or maybe they need to be posted to the photos section? I don't know how the group is set up.
While it's hard to compare radios between vehicles, if your 4Runner had an external antenna -- the traditional metal rod -- it's understandable that that would probably work better than one that is in the glass. I recall reading about people installing a traditional antenna to improve reception in cars that came with those in the windshield or rear window. It is also possible that the noise floor in the new Ford is much higher at AM band frequencies than it was in the Toyota. This could make it harder to receive a signal that weakens with distance. |
Re: How do you measure a car antenna?
At the risk of being slightly OT, there are several reasons that AM radios are disappearing. One is the EMI problem caused by various vehicle charging and propulsion systems. The EMI issue is a discussion topic on forums frequented by public safety and commercial two-way radio techs.
European car makers have dropped AM because it has been supplanted by DAB and AM stations are shutting down there, leaving little to listen to. Major US car makers disclaim any intention to abandon AM but we'll have to wait and see. In major US metro areas some of the AM stations are now simulcasting on FM so that they don't lose their audience. Many of us have noted that the AM radios in older cars with traditional external metal rod antennas work better than the in the glass antennas. |
Re: Not available at Ali Express / Zeenko
I see all of the products listed. Please note that product visibility
toggle quoted message
Show quoted text
depends on your country of delivery. A year or so back I could not see any products in his store unless I changed my shipping country. Your VIsa card problems are due to your card issuer/bank. On Sat, 26 Aug 2023 at 15:07, G4OJW <g4ojw@...> wrote:
|
to navigate to use esc to dismiss