¿ªÔÆÌåÓý

ctrl + shift + ? for shortcuts
© 2025 Groups.io
Date
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Andy, The high loss R is, I believe, from the toroid ferrite material. This is why they are used for RF suppression, e.g. common mode choke baluns. K9YC has lots of material on this. See, e.g.,
By Roger · #25167 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
That's what I see when I hook up my Harbor Freight special to a Tek scope! And on a Fluke meter as well. Kent
By KENT BRITAIN · #25166 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Agreed, but isn¡¯t that R, divided into X at 1 MHz, going to give me Q? It will be terrible. I expected a toroid to offer higher Q than an air core¡­
By Andrew Kurtz <adkurtz@...> · #25165 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Type J (75) was my first thought also, but his numbers, 1Mhz, 180uh and 200 ohms R, is a Q of 5 or 6 and I think that is much to low, unless he used some high resistance wire. To Kent, I have two
By Mikek · #25164 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
This cannot be a powdered iron core. I do not know of any powdered iron cores that have an AL value of 50,000 uH/100T. It has to be a ferrite core. Zack W9SZ
By Zack Widup · #25163 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Check the units of your toroid chart - not everyone used the same scale, I've seen? uH/100 turns, mH/100 turns and others as uH/turns^2 L (mH) = AL(mH/turns^2) * 36 0.180 = AL * 36? -> 0.005
By Jim Lux · #25162 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Here are sites that indicate the frequency range over which powdered iron cores are best applied, max Q. Powdered iron cores are designed for a specific frequency range to maximize the Q of inductors
By W0LEV · #25161 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
The closest thing I see to that is the Amidon type J ferrite toroids. Useful frequency range is 1 to 15 MHz for type J. They don't specify a size exactly the same, but the FT87-J is the closest they
By Zack Widup · #25160 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
That 200 Ohms is not the same as a 200 Ohm resistor at any frequency other that 1 MHz. Again Impedance, not resistance.? Kent
By KENT BRITAIN · #25159 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Thanks, but I must disagree: the nanoVNA provides a resistance output as well as a reactance, and that is what I was reading to be 200 ohms at 1 MHz...
By Andrew Kurtz <adkurtz@...> · #25158 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Not really resistance, but impdeance. Got a good old DC Volt Ohm Meter? Try that, but you see only 1 or 2 Ohms. Most of the Digital VOM;s are using pulses that are much like RF.So they are reading as
By KENT BRITAIN · #25157 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
This thread inspires me to ask a question that is not directly about my nanoVNA: I have a toroid from a flea market that is blue, has OD = 0.875¡±, ID = 0.51¡±, and length = 0.3125¡±. I wrapped 6
By Andrew Kurtz <adkurtz@...> · #25156 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
You don't need anything other than the NANOVNAs to measure inductance as a function of frequency. Invoke the Smith Chart, and use the cursors to measure the L at any frequency within your sweep.
By W0LEV · #25155 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
On Sat, 16 Oct 2021 Cliff <mailto:kd4gt.tn@...?subject=Re:%20%22Q%22%2C%20Coils%2C%20toroids%2C%20and%20guesswork%3F> wrote about an on line toroid calculator available at:
By Tom McKee K4ZAD <tom.m@...> · #25154 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
Some may find this does-it-all calculator useful also. It is my go to site for all things toroid. ¡­. and even obvious and easy to remember and get to. Just type the following in the address bar of
By Gary O'Neil · #25153 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
I would find it interesting to see curves of L(uh) at different B field amplitudes. Such as with a weak antenna signal vs an amplifier output. I learned in my first AC circuits class that AsubL drops
By Mikek · #25152 ·
Re: "Q", Coils, toroids, and guesswork?
I contacted the author of the program (Miguel Vaca) by email and sent him my suggestions and bug report. He has just released a new version which plots L versus frequency. Those designing toroid
By Roger Need · #25151 ·
Re: Windows 10 H4 Driver
Everything helps.. Thanks!
By Andy-kf7vol <a9il8tr@...> · #25150 ·
Re: Calibration
Jim, I agree with you. Here are some measurements of a 20M dipole. First measurement was made using calibrated range of 1 to 30 MHz. Next was using same calibration but "zooming in" to 13
By Roger Need · #25149 ·
Re: Calibration
Barring pathological cases
By Jim Lux · #25148 ·