开云体育


Re: Networking first needs (was Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP)

 

Drew Derbyshire wrote:

On 10/19/19 4:01 PM, Timothy Stark wrote:

Does anyone plan to develop new TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6 system since
IBM's TCP/IP software is not available?
THAT question I like.
My long term plan is to leverage the TCP/IP and IUCV support I've written for
Hercules to support TCP/IP on MUSIC/SP. This requires adding IUCV support
to VM/370 R6 which I've started but it's going to take a while.


Second, I've seen documentation that says REXX on VM/370 R6 is flaky.?
Fix it.?? (You'll need it for TCP/IP tools).
I think EXECIO support is the most urgent requirement.


Third, you need a more modern RSCS and its associated tools:

* RSCS server that matches the RSCS V1R3 Program Product documentation
on BitSavers, supporting:
o remote commands
o remote operators
o store and forward of files
o forwarding of messages
o routing to distant systems
I think I've got pretty much all of the above done execpt for remote operators.
It's not released yet but I've given it to anyone who wants to try it out.

Haven't I told you about this already Drew?


* IDENTIFY
I've written a hack to do this some time ago. I should dig it up and see about
getting it finished.


* NAMEFIND
* NAMES
I wouldn't regard these as a priority. We can think about them when we
get to the point of having so many people to communicate with that we
cannot remember who is who. REXX with EXECIO should go a long way to
implementing them.


* SENDFILE
You forgot to mention RECEIVE. I've done limited hacks for both SENDFILE and
RECEIVE. They need some more work but they are not as cumbersome as
SPOOL PUN / TAG DEV PUN / PUNCH and ORDER / READCARD and they have some
limited NETDATA support too.


* NOTE
* BSMTP gateway for mail
I haven't done anything on these yet.


You won't have chat without TCP/IP (below), but I think it would be
worth the wait.
I wouldn't regard it as a priority. I'm very close to be able to do chat
over NJE. I don't see any compelling reason to have TCP/IP based chat from
VM.


Fourth, consider TCP/IP and its associated tools:

1. TCP/IP server which uses the API of the IBM TCP/IP V1R2 as much as
possible.
The API is critical because it allows public domain software to be
backported.
MUSIC/SP uses the IUCV form of that API to do TCP/IP so this is what I'm
aiming at implementing for VM/CMS long term. Unfortunately, some public
domain software may also use the VMCF API. It would be easier to
implement the clients with the simpler VMCF interface too. However,
using VMCF means having to implement some sort of TCPIP virtual machine
server to traslate from VMCF into something that can get outside of VM
to a TCP/IP network and that is quite beyond me.


2. The RXSOCKET library adapted for the VM/370 implementation of TCP/IP
and REXX.
Not much use until REXX can do basic stuff like EXECIO.


3. RSCS tools (above) adapted for TCP/IP.
I don't know what you mean here.


4. TELNET server
I'm not sure I see the need for a telnet server when Hercules already has
this built in.


5. mail gateway
My suggestion is to move the mail off system using NJE to a system which
can gateway it to the SMTP world. I think this was often a preferable way
to do it anyway because IBM's SMTP server implementaion for VM was not great.


6. mail client
I've got some ideas but not done anything. Can't do everything.


7. file retrieval clients
8. IRC client

That's pretty long list right there.

Don't bother with writing servers that you can connect to off-system:

* Chat servers
* Internet-facing Mail servers
* Mailing list servers
* File servers (VMARC files on UNIX file servers are good enough for
IBM, so they're good enough for us)
I'm close to being able to do a file server now so that's where I'm going
with it.

Regards,
Peter Coghlan.


Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP.

 

From the original author of the Pascal version of Relay:
Between VT moving away from VM/XA as part of Y2K and the demise of
Bitnet, it's been a long time since I've been sure I knew where the
RELAY source was. Even if I had a copy, he'd need a legal copy of the
Pascal/VS compiler to build it (I used that because Clarkson had a
license for it, and the licensing on the runtime allowed me to ship a
RELAYV2 MODULE that had the runtime linked in. The C compilers for VM
didn't allow that.) I admit being surprised that anybody still has an
RSCS network large enough to make running RELAY worthwhile. Also,
unless he has a VM system that does IUCV, the Relay code won't work.
And if we're talking VM/370 R6 that won't fly. If he's on VM/SP R6
that would be a different story.
Someone is working on RSCS and IUCV for VM/370 R6. I have good knowledge of pascal language so that I can port that to other modern C language.

There are many IRCD source codes on github and others for Internet.

Does anyone have any copy of Relay V1 (REXX version)? I know that Relay V2 is Pascal version. I used Relay on BITNET while I was student at University.


Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP.

 

Hi,

there already IS a TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6: it is the NICOF package which can be found in the files section of the original H390-VM files section as well as the equivalent section of the groups.io group. It can furthermore be found at github (

It is based on VMCF (not IUCV, not available in R6), using proxy-VMs for various sevices interfacing external Java programs which provide the "real" communication services, being the real-machine TCP/IP sockets in case of the TCP/IP stack. The TCP/IP stack provided by NICOF is similar to the bsd-socket API. The newest version 0.7.0 provides both SOCK_STREAM and SOCK_DGRAM sockets (version 0.6.0 only STREAM sockets). There is also a FTP server for a CMS virtual machine, so accessing CMS files from the outside with your preferred FTP client program is easy (even with drag and drop, if your ftp client does it).?
All this is more or less well documented in the PDF of the distributions, along with installing in various scenarios, the easiest being the playground installation in a freshly unpacked Sixpack 1.2 system.

Greetings
Hans

(this thread came to my attention as i received a notification that some Hercules group was migrated to groups.io, so i became aware of the whole migration story and i registered to some of the new hercules-related groups... Many thanks to all who take care of the Hercules, VM, MVS etc. knownledge not going lost!)


Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP.

 

Timothy Stark wrote:


I reviewed some recent replies about Listserv software for VM/CMS R6 system.
Sad world, they can't find old Listserv copies so far.
Who said anything about "can't find"? I said that I misremembered asking
about old Listserv code. It turns out I had been asking about something
else entirely therefore I know nothing at all about the status of old
Listserv code.


Does anyone plan to re-write Listserv server from scratch or so?
That seems a bit premature.


Also I hope that someone could find RELAY (both Rexx and Pascal sources) and
XYZZY software for communications. That is similar like IRC chat for
Internet. I had a copy of XYZZY with sources but lost them due to my hard
drive failure. Does anyone still have a copy of XYZZY chat program with
source codes?
I don't have either, never had.


Does anyone plan to develop new TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6 system since
IBM's TCP/IP software is not available?
I have an idea for this but given my record on other stuff, it's going to
take a while before anything usable appears.

Regards,
Peter Coghlan.


Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP.

 

On 10/19/19 4:01 PM, Timothy Stark wrote:
I reviewed some recent replies about Listserv software for VM/CMS R6 system.
Sad world, they can't find old Listserv copies so far. Does anyone plan to
re-write Listserv server from scratch or so?

Also I hope that someone could find RELAY (both Rexx and Pascal sources) and
XYZZY software for communications. That is similar like IRC chat for
Internet. I had a copy of XYZZY with sources but lost them due to my hard
drive failure. Does anyone still have a copy of XYZZY chat program with
source codes?

Does anyone plan to develop new TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6 system since
From the original author of the Pascal version of Relay:

Between VT moving away from VM/XA as part of Y2K and the demise of Bitnet, it's been a long time since I've been sure I knew where the RELAY source was. Even if I had a copy, he'd need a legal copy of the Pascal/VS compiler to build it (I used that because Clarkson had a license for it, and the licensing on the runtime allowed me to ship a RELAYV2 MODULE that had the runtime linked in. The C compilers for VM didn't allow that.) I admit being surprised that anybody still has an RSCS network large enough to make running RELAY worthwhile. Also, unless he has a VM system that does IUCV, the Relay code won't work. And if we're talking VM/370 R6 that won't fly. If he's on VM/SP R6 that would be a different story.


Networking first needs (was Re: Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP)

 

开云体育

On 10/19/19 4:01 PM, Timothy Stark wrote:
I reviewed some recent replies about Listserv software for VM/CMS R6 system.
Sad world, they can't find old Listserv copies so far.   Does anyone plan to
re-write Listserv server from scratch or so?
You're getting ahead of yourself. Don't worry about application servers like LISTSERV (yet).
Also I hope that someone could find RELAY (both Rexx and Pascal sources) and
XYZZY software for communications.  That is similar like IRC chat for
Internet.   I had a copy of XYZZY with sources but lost them due to my hard
drive failure.  
So pull them off your backup. (That's the SRE in me talking, oops.)
Does anyone still have a copy of XYZZY chat program with
source codes?
Ditto for worrying these if they can't be found.
Does anyone plan to develop new TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6 system since
IBM's TCP/IP software is not available?

THAT question I like.

I would suggest the following priorities:

First, be glad you're not talking MVS.? RSCS drops into VM/370 R6, and VM R6 even has TAG support.? OTOH, MVS NJE would require major hacks in JES2.

Second, I've seen documentation that says REXX on VM/370 R6 is flaky.? Fix it.?? (You'll need it for TCP/IP tools).

Third, you need a more modern RSCS and its associated tools:
  • RSCS server that matches the RSCS V1R3 Program Product documentation on BitSavers, supporting:
    • remote commands
    • remote operators
    • store and forward of files
    • forwarding of messages
    • routing to distant systems
  • IDENTIFY
  • NAMEFIND
  • NAMES
  • SENDFILE
  • NOTE
  • BSMTP gateway for mail

You won't have chat without TCP/IP (below), but I think it would be worth the wait.

Fourth, consider TCP/IP and its associated tools:
  1. TCP/IP server which uses the API of the IBM TCP/IP V1R2 as much as possible.?
    The API is critical because it allows public domain software to be backported.
  2. The RXSOCKET library adapted for the VM/370 implementation of TCP/IP and REXX.
  3. RSCS tools (above) adapted for TCP/IP.
  4. TELNET server
  5. mail gateway
  6. mail client
  7. file retrieval clients
  8. IRC client

That's pretty long list right there.?

Don't bother with writing servers that you can connect to off-system:

  • Chat servers
  • Internet-facing Mail servers
  • Mailing list servers
  • File servers (VMARC files on UNIX file servers are good enough for IBM, so they're good enough for us)

-ahd-


Listserv, Relay, Xyzzy and TCP/IP.

 

I reviewed some recent replies about Listserv software for VM/CMS R6 system.
Sad world, they can't find old Listserv copies so far. Does anyone plan to
re-write Listserv server from scratch or so?

Also I hope that someone could find RELAY (both Rexx and Pascal sources) and
XYZZY software for communications. That is similar like IRC chat for
Internet. I had a copy of XYZZY with sources but lost them due to my hard
drive failure. Does anyone still have a copy of XYZZY chat program with
source codes?

Does anyone plan to develop new TCP/IP stack for VM/CMS R6 system since
IBM's TCP/IP software is not available?

Tim


Re: Lists and Hercules and LSoft

 

Gregg Levine wrote:

Oh okay good reason. back them they just did not want to explain what
did happen. Did they say how old these tapes were? And what sort of
drive would have been used for them? I think Dave M here must have the
style of tape drive it would have been used on.
I finally managed to locate the email exchange in question in my mail archives.
It turned out to be from nine years ago and unfortunately, my memory has been
playing tricks on me :-(

It was copies of old BITEARN NODES files that Lsoft had stashed on old 6250bpi
round tapes, not old copies of Listserv software. Unfortunately, I have no
information about how Lsoft feels about hobbyists running old versions of
Listserv after all. Sorry for raising hopes.

Regards,
Peter Coghlan.


Re: Test!

 

test


Re: Lists and Hercules and LSoft

 

Hello!
Oh okay good reason. back them they just did not want to explain what
did happen. Did they say how old these tapes were? And what sort of
drive would have been used for them? I think Dave M here must have the
style of tape drive it would have been used on.

Oh and Peter funny thing, right after the message I am replying to, is
the request from the list-bot for me to confirm your message.

Dave they are done. It worked, and the target won't be able to do
anything for a week.
-----
Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8@...
"This signature fought the Time Wars, time and again."

On Sat, Oct 19, 2019 at 3:00 AM Peter Coghlan <groups@...> wrote:

Gregg Levine wrote:


Back when Hercules was still growing up and the original list was not
as big as it is now, I made an interesting suggestion; Basically we
could find out if the list server software from LSoft was still
available from VM, we could track down a copy and get to run on
Hercules running VM/370 Release 6.
I approached Lsoft about this some years ago. As far as I recall, the
response back then was fairly positive but there were a number of snags.
Firstly, Listserv for VM was archived on old tapes and no working drive
was available to read them. Secondly, it is not going to run on VM/370 R6
without a lot of work. It's about 30 years since I last saw Listserv on
VM but as far as I recall, it is mostly written in REXX. I suspect it
makes a lot of use of EXECIO which I don't think we have at present.
There are other smaller issues but I think this one is the showstopper at
the moment.


Naturally this was before I found out that two things did happen, one
of them was that LSoft made the bad decision to get out of the list
server on the appropriate IBM mainframe that we would be emulating for
VM/370 Release 6. The second was that of how such a mainframe would
find itself connected to the Internet. And naturally running that
release. It's possible that IBM did create a preliminary stack for
networking via TCP/IP protocols but, sadly a lot of the software we
would need is not available.
The good news is that having TCP/IP connectivity on VM/370 R6 is not a
requirement to run Listserv. On VM, Listserv exchanged mail in the form
of spool files with a mail transfer agent (such as Lsoft Lmail or the
Crosswell Mailer) on the same VM system or with an off-system MTA by
sending the spool files over NJE links to other systems. The latter is
possible now on VM/370 R6 so mail can be transferred to an external system
which has TCP/IP connectivity where it can be gatewayed into the SMTP world.

I have an NJE link set up to my VMS system (running HUJI-NJE) which can get
mail to and from the outside by routing it through the PMDF MTA on VMS.
This is a bit fragile yet and there are issues with preventing spam etc but
it seems to work most of the time.

None of this is is likely to turn into a viable replacement for Yahoo
groups before they go away (although Listserv can host files in general as
well as mailing lists) but it is fun to play with.

Regards,
Peter Coghlan.



Re: Lists and Hercules and LSoft

 

Gregg Levine wrote:


Back when Hercules was still growing up and the original list was not
as big as it is now, I made an interesting suggestion; Basically we
could find out if the list server software from LSoft was still
available from VM, we could track down a copy and get to run on
Hercules running VM/370 Release 6.
I approached Lsoft about this some years ago. As far as I recall, the
response back then was fairly positive but there were a number of snags.
Firstly, Listserv for VM was archived on old tapes and no working drive
was available to read them. Secondly, it is not going to run on VM/370 R6
without a lot of work. It's about 30 years since I last saw Listserv on
VM but as far as I recall, it is mostly written in REXX. I suspect it
makes a lot of use of EXECIO which I don't think we have at present.
There are other smaller issues but I think this one is the showstopper at
the moment.


Naturally this was before I found out that two things did happen, one
of them was that LSoft made the bad decision to get out of the list
server on the appropriate IBM mainframe that we would be emulating for
VM/370 Release 6. The second was that of how such a mainframe would
find itself connected to the Internet. And naturally running that
release. It's possible that IBM did create a preliminary stack for
networking via TCP/IP protocols but, sadly a lot of the software we
would need is not available.
The good news is that having TCP/IP connectivity on VM/370 R6 is not a
requirement to run Listserv. On VM, Listserv exchanged mail in the form
of spool files with a mail transfer agent (such as Lsoft Lmail or the
Crosswell Mailer) on the same VM system or with an off-system MTA by
sending the spool files over NJE links to other systems. The latter is
possible now on VM/370 R6 so mail can be transferred to an external system
which has TCP/IP connectivity where it can be gatewayed into the SMTP world.

I have an NJE link set up to my VMS system (running HUJI-NJE) which can get
mail to and from the outside by routing it through the PMDF MTA on VMS.
This is a bit fragile yet and there are issues with preventing spam etc but
it seems to work most of the time.

None of this is is likely to turn into a viable replacement for Yahoo
groups before they go away (although Listserv can host files in general as
well as mailing lists) but it is fun to play with.

Regards,
Peter Coghlan.


Lists and Hercules and LSoft

 

Hello!
Back when Hercules was still growing up and the original list was not
as big as it is now, I made an interesting suggestion; Basically we
could find out if the list server software from LSoft was still
available from VM, we could track down a copy and get to run on
Hercules running VM/370 Release 6.

Naturally this was before I found out that two things did happen, one
of them was that LSoft made the bad decision to get out of the list
server on the appropriate IBM mainframe that we would be emulating for
VM/370 Release 6. The second was that of how such a mainframe would
find itself connected to the Internet. And naturally running that
release. It's possible that IBM did create a preliminary stack for
networking via TCP/IP protocols but, sadly a lot of the software we
would need is not available.

I found out about LSoft making that mistake at a trade show for the PC
about the same time I met an R/370. The R/370 made a better impression
than the droids from LSoft.

Who here (now) would know which release of VM prior to the Z Branded
releases did have networking available? I do know that Cliff Stoll
mentions what we run and the MVS crowd in his book.

Oh and Dave M? Please stop staring. The group does need all six to
make things work.
-----
Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8@...
"This signature fought the Time Wars, time and again."


Re: Files

 

On October 18, 2019 6:32:24 PM "Dave Wade" <dave.g4ugm@...> wrote:
OK Folks, I have copied the "files" without the annotations, to this group.
I will try and annotate them over the next few days.
Thank you for your efforts!

-Dave

--
Dave McGuire, AK4HZ
New Kensington, PA


Files

 

开云体育

OK Folks, I have copied the “files” without the annotations, to this group.? I will try and annotate them over the next few days.

?

Dave Wade

G4UGM & EA7KAE

?


Re: Hi

 

Thanks for doing the transfer, it certainly looks good.

Eddy Balem


Re: Hi

Richard Harper
 

开云体育

Already joined both!



Sent from my Samsung Galaxy smartphone.

-------- Original message --------
From: Dave Wade <dave.g4ugm@...>
Date: 18/10/2019 08:12 (GMT+00:00)
Subject: Re: [h390-vm] Hi

I have moved some files. Will nominally have until December to move the files and images, but given Yahoos record on file access it may break with the load as every one decamps.
I only created H390-MTS (Which I own) and this one (because love VM and wanted to by-pass the dithering that’s? going on in Hercules-390)

Dave

> -----Original Message-----
> From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Gregg Levine
> Sent: 18 October 2019 02:04
> To: [email protected]
> Subject: Re: [h390-vm] Hi
>
> Hello!
> Yes indeed. All is well. Now we need to encourage the remaining members on
> the list to join. By the way? Who delivered the archive of file items? I'm not
> worried about the printer output items I've uploaded. That can be reproduced
> any time I need to ask about them, but, ah, who do I thank for it? Oh and Dave
> W? Did you create the group next door on MVS? We still need to spin up the
> one for DOSVS as it happens.
> -----
> Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8@...
> "This signature fought the Time Wars, time and again."
>
> On Thu, Oct 17, 2019 at 8:54 PM Thomas Kern via Groups.Io
> <TLK_sysprog@...> wrote:
> >
> > I used the wrong email for the last join to this group. This email is the one I
> use for Computer topics.
> >
> > /Tom Kern
> >
>
>






Re: Hi

 

I have moved some files. Will nominally have until December to move the files and images, but given Yahoos record on file access it may break with the load as every one decamps.
I only created H390-MTS (Which I own) and this one (because love VM and wanted to by-pass the dithering that’s going on in Hercules-390)

Dave

-----Original Message-----
From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Gregg Levine
Sent: 18 October 2019 02:04
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [h390-vm] Hi

Hello!
Yes indeed. All is well. Now we need to encourage the remaining members on
the list to join. By the way? Who delivered the archive of file items? I'm not
worried about the printer output items I've uploaded. That can be reproduced
any time I need to ask about them, but, ah, who do I thank for it? Oh and Dave
W? Did you create the group next door on MVS? We still need to spin up the
one for DOSVS as it happens.
-----
Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8@...
"This signature fought the Time Wars, time and again."

On Thu, Oct 17, 2019 at 8:54 PM Thomas Kern via Groups.Io
<TLK_sysprog@...> wrote:

I used the wrong email for the last join to this group. This email is the one I
use for Computer topics.

/Tom Kern


Re: Hi

 

开云体育

Folks,

?

You can change your e-mail address on the web site without re-subscribing. You can also log in without a password. If go to the groups.io home page and are not logged in, just pop your E-Mail address in the top box and click the “e-mail me a link to log in” and that’s what will happen. Once logged in you can use the box top right to “view account” and then there is a “change e-mail” right below your e-mail address.

?

You can set a password and log-in in the normal way, or link a facebook or google account. Might be worth setting your timezone, display name and checking few a few of the other settings.

?

Dave

?

From: [email protected] <[email protected]> On Behalf Of Thomas Kern via Groups.Io
Sent: 18 October 2019 01:47
To: [email protected]
Subject: Re: [h390-vm] Hi

?

I used the wrong email for the last join to this group. This email is the one I use for Computer topics.

/Tom Kern


Re: Hi

 

Hello!
Yes indeed. All is well. Now we need to encourage the remaining
members on the list to join. By the way? Who delivered the archive of
file items? I'm not worried about the printer output items I've
uploaded. That can be reproduced any time I need to ask about them,
but, ah, who do I thank for it? Oh and Dave W? Did you create the
group next door on MVS? We still need to spin up the one for DOSVS as
it happens.
-----
Gregg C Levine gregg.drwho8@...
"This signature fought the Time Wars, time and again."

On Thu, Oct 17, 2019 at 8:54 PM Thomas Kern via Groups.Io
<TLK_sysprog@...> wrote:

I used the wrong email for the last join to this group. This email is the one I use for Computer topics.

/Tom Kern


Re: Hi

 

I used the wrong email for the last join to this group. This email is the one I use for Computer topics.

/Tom Kern