Re: 333P - MPC coordinates far off
Hi Thomas, I imaged this comet last night 20241126_27. I used the MPC ephemeris in Astrometrica to measure with. My astrometry as submitted to MPC last night is attached. I hope this helps. Best
By
Denis Buczynski
·
#33046
·
|
Re: 333P - MPC coordinates far off
Hi Thomas, The ephemeris provided via the MPC includes: "Perturbed ephemeris below is based on elements from MPEC 2020-L06." so it is not surprising that the ephemeris is out compared to JPL. The MPC
By
Peter Birtwhistle
·
#33045
·
|
333P - MPC coordinates far off
I am currently doing some work on older images and noticed a large difference in coordinates of 333P between MPC and JPL. While the latter are very close to the position of the comet in the image the
By
Thomas Lehmann
·
#33044
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
Hi Adrien and all! There's the beautiful Theory of Probability playing amazing tricks here and there! The initial assumption of Adrien's calculation was as follows:
By
Denis Denisenko
·
#33043
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
All, these might be interesting to read: L. Kresak: A Strange Anomaly in the Occurence Rate of Old Comets https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1981BAICz..32..147K/abstract l. Kresak: On the Reality and
By
Maik Meyer
·
#33042
·
|
Comet 333P/LINEAR now in SWAN
Hi All. Just for information. Recent moderate bright comet 333P/LINEAR now is visible in the last SWAN images with X-Y position (0,0 - upper left): 25/11 342-239. Brightness in the level of +12m based
By
Vladimir Bezugly
·
#33041
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
After looking a bit deeper, I found this paper which identified the relevant comet cluster, although it doesn't identify an obvious candidate stellar flyby:
By
Qicheng Zhang
·
#33040
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
Hi Qicheng, HD 7977 is the only (currently known) star that might have produced currently-observable influence on the Oort Cloud during its approach to 30,200 +6600 -4900 AU, 2.76 million years ago.
By
planetaryscience@...
·
#33039
·
|
Re: C/2024 G3 and it further behavior
To follow up about the prospects for comet 2024 G3 ATLAS, I made the same kind of tail simulations as for comet Tsuchinshan-ATLAS. Besides what has already been said about the unfavorable viewing
By
Nico Lefaudeux
·
#33038
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
First, a few minor notes that probably don't change the overall problem but matter if you want to calculate a proper expectation value: 1. The difference between any two sets of node/peri can't be
By
Qicheng Zhang
·
#33037
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
Hi Maik, Thank you, interesting. Adrien [email protected]> a ¨¦crit :
By
Adrien Coffinet
·
#33036
·
|
Re: Comets with similar orbits
Hello Adrien, But it i
By
Maik Meyer
·
#33035
·
|
Comets with similar orbits
Hi all, My question may be stupid, but I have found a few pairs of quasi-parabolic comets with nearly exactly the same angles (i, peri, node), the main difference being their perihelion distance. If,
By
Adrien Coffinet
·
#33034
·
|
Re: Viewing geometry for comet ATLAS, war Re: C/2024 G3 and it further behavior
If Comet C/2023 A3 (Tsuchinshan-ATLAS) had actually been magnitude -3 as seen from "Earth" on October 10 it would have been very easy to see given that the comet set well after the Sun set, it would
By
Mike Olason
·
#33033
·
|
Re: Viewing geometry for comet ATLAS, war Re: C/2024 G3 and it further behavior
Hello all Is it possible, that the comet could observe at the daylight, if it survives? Greetings Anja Verh?fen Alexander Balashov via groups.io <skywatcher422@...> schrieb am Mo.,
By
Anja Verh?fen
·
#33032
·
|
Re: Viewing geometry for comet ATLAS, war Re: C/2024 G3 and it further behavior
Coma c/2024 g3 is likely to be more condensed than coma c/2023 a3, because c/2024 g3 will be further from Earth and mag -3 will be reached by close approach to the Sun rather than by forward
By
Alexander Balashov
·
#33031
·
Edited
|
Viewing geometry for comet ATLAS, war Re: C/2024 G3 and it further behavior
Can we predict the (non-)visibility of C/2024 G3 around peak brightness in strong twilight from the recent experience with C/2023 A3's around its solar conjunction? The following assumes a) that G3
By
Daniel Fischer
·
#33030
·
|
Re: Comets 37P/Forbes and C/2023 C2 (ATLAS) Conjunction
Hi David, I routinely image comets brighter than magnitude 15 that are visible from Tucson, Arizona to calculate the magnitudes of these comets. I started imaging 37P and C/2023 C2 in early September
By
Mike Olason
·
#33029
·
|
Re: Comets 37P/Forbes and C/2023 C2 (ATLAS) Conjunction
Very nice work Mike! Where did you discover this conjunction may I ask? Running JPLHorizons I find the time of closest approach (GEOCENTRIC) was 5.64 arcseconds on Nov.19d 23:32UT ( I think parallax
By
David Moore(Ireland)
·
#33028
·
|
Re: Comets 37P/Forbes and C/2023 C2 (ATLAS) Conjunction
Astrometrica software used several hundred stars in the FOV to determine that my old eyes using only a few stars did not do a very good job of estimating the comets magnitude in the animation above.
By
Mike Olason
·
#33027
·
|