--- In yardbirdtrains@..., "emmettdene" wrote:
yep just plain old drug store rubbing alcohol.also works good on your pruning shears in the rose garden.
emmet d
--- In yardbirdtrains@..., Tom Knowles wrote:
Emmit, did you mean denatured alcohol? I thought the rubbing stuff had a
lubricant in it...I did not know this insulating property of Goo Gone
either, which I sometimes use. Since I always have lacquer thinner here
and in small bottles on the workbench, that's what I usually use to
clean wheels and track with excellent results.
A thought about traction differences in scintered wheels smooth or NS
tires: My old Athearn units have either of these two driving wheel set-ups.
1) NWSL which I believe are machined and polished NS, seldom need
cleaning and traction is within my limits. I have one engine with
Jay-Bee wheelsets that is so-so.
2) polished scintered Athearn wheels. I never allow an Athearn to escape
my shop without this step. See below:
Athearn wheels, though porous and rough as we know (perhaps aiding
traction a bit), get a shine that seems to help prevent dirt build-up
and aids current pick up. I've noticed no reduction in TE, but I seldom
work my engines to the limit. Since I always disassemble the trucks to
clean and lubricate as well as check for the chronic cracked gear
syndrome I remove all wheels when I build or repair an Athearn engine. I
put the wheel/axle stub in a drill press, and polish the tread surface
in three steps. Start with 400 emery and go to 600, then 800 or1000 grit
autobody emery with the part spinning pretty fast. I have run the pair
of F's at the museum two years now with no cleaning of wheels. Zero.
These two dedicated Museum property Athearn F's are both powered "super
power", pulling a string of 7 stainless redetailed Athearn cars. All but
one car has wipers on the axles for interior lights, adding to the drag.
There is one grade for them each time around of about 2% with a reverse
curve. Using transistor throttles on a fixed setting, they
prototypically slow down there. I've never detected a slip, but not
loaded them to the max as in a long freight consist.
I traded my BLI heavy Mike w/ DCC and sound (L&N 1776) to a fellow near
here for a DC sound equipped version BLI light Mike. The new engine will
become another NC&StL steamer, but for use at the museum on DC which is
preferred for simplicity. Sound is a big hit with visitors. The DC with
sound is interesting, and runs great. The sound is good, pretty-well
synchronized and sharp cut-offs till it gets to above maybe 50MPH, then
becomes a weird "shuffle". The engine I traded was DOA to the other guy,
much to my embarrassment having never failed me. We met at the store
where we did this swap to t-shoot(The Dixie Flyer, Wartrace
Tennssee...trackside on the old NC&StL) and yes, the engine was dead.
Shorted! Nothing getting hot except the power pack. I did a few things
and did some disassembly and re-checks, never finding a thing wrong. Put
the engine back together and lo-an-behold!, she works fine now. Not a
clue as to what was wrong. When I was in Industrial Electronic repair,
I ran into this scenario most of the time. One particular motor
controller kept coming back to us as non-functioning, and we never found
a problem with it. We finally decided the unit just like the looks of
the technician, so we took a picture of him and taped it inside the
cover. It shipped back to the customer with evidently never another
trouble. Electronics: BAHHH.
Health-wise I am much better, but have no stamina. Working on that....
Tom Knowles
On 1/7/2013 4:00 AM, emmettdene wrote:
rubbing alcohol works great for cleaning track. leaves no residue.
emmet d
--- In yardbirdtrains@...
, Mike Bauers wrote:
Goo Gone cleans and leaves an insulating layer behind. I've used it
and seen the layout go dead as a result the following morning.
Do try any kind of tuner cleaner on those wheels. Or go to one of
the good hardware stores, auto parts supply stores, or marine supply
stores and get a can of the electronic cleaner and conditioner you
find there.
Most of the time its a CRC product
Advanced Auto Parts has " CRC QD? Electronic Cleaner" for a bit over
$7 in a large spray can. Wet a Q-tip with it and wipe the driver tires
and other electrical surfaces with it.
You can do the same with your rails [wipe about 6-inches every
several feet apart then drive around the layout] and you'll see a
marked operating improvement in a matter of seconds.
Do the complete electrical path on the loco's and your track switch
points and you'll feel like you have gold plated electrical contacts
on everything. That includes even old zamak slabs that are part of the
electrical path on old models, treat contact points and any screws
that are part of the electrical paths.
Case in point, it makes an ancient Athearn 0-4-2t Little Monster
that is largely a zamak electrical path and has sat for 20 years, run
like a new Kato after that treatment.... that and a wisp of fresh oil
and axle lube in the right places. This is my personal experience with
the stuff and that model as well as many others. Models that simply
never were known to run decently in the first place.
Don't overlook places like the body pads under the tender trucks and
the place where the washer like connector wire goes between the
locomotive and the tender. Back off such screws and wipe both the
threads and the contact area under the screw heads and the connector
'washer', then snug down to working positions.
I'm certain you will be amazed at how much better the model operates
when you have conditioned the electrical points that have become
oxidized and thus somewhat insulated over time........ with just a
certain fluid.
Best to ya...
Mike Bauers
Milwaukee, Wi, USA
On Jan 6, 2013, at 12:44 PM, twilight022765 wrote:
John, one of the guys in my earlier posts responded with a product
he recommends called Flitz, which I just order last night on Amazon.
My drivers on my H9 are brass(probably worn down to the brass???). I
have used Goo Gone to clean them. But, as he mentioned about his club,
my club's rails can get quite dirty and maybe the Goo Gone isn't doing
the trick anymore. So, I want to give that a try. The reason for the
question was, my L1, that is set up the same way as my H9 is operating
rather nicely and has the NS drivers. It's like some one put a
resistor in line with the motor on the H9. This will be my last try to
improve the conductivity before I add the pickups.
Thanks again to everyone who has offered their helpful advice.
Mark
--- In yardbirdtrains@...
, "John Hagen" wrote:
Well I can't say much about brass vs NS but I can speak from
experience
about the difference between sintered metal and NS. By actual
comparison NS
has comparatively poor adhesion on NS track.
My "Athearn" Baldwin S-12 with an Cary built (lead-antimony) Cary
Alco S-2
shell along with added lead, a Sagami 2032 motor w/brass
flywheels and Ernst
gears was able to easily switch a cut of 56 5 oz. 40 ft. freight
cars, all
with C.V. trucks on my friends (Cal) layout. After the switch to
NWSL NS
wheels it hard a hard time moving anything over 40 of the cars in
the yard.
That coincided with Cal's change to Command Control but that
really had
nothing to do with it as the problem was wheel slip.
Although not a direct comparison, my thoughts are that brass
wheels would
have similar traction to the sintered metal. Having started on HO
around
1949 I have much experience with brass drive wheels.
So far as cleanliness if one's track is clean kept brass and
sintered metal
work just fine. So far as electrical pick-up all will work okay
but I agree
that NS gets a bit of the nod here. A more important
consideration to me is
having reasonable clean rail without being so clean and dry that
arcing is
promoted.
|
